COP 29
#31
(11-13-2024, 07:54 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Heat networks are perfect for cities

I assume you read this in The Times last week. Thoughts?

" I am going to set you a multiple-choice question. You’re a local council in charge of several large housing estates. I want you to identify which of these two situations constitutes an “emergency”.


Situation A is that of Charlwood House, a building owned and managed by the council but leased to A2Dominion, which is full of social housing tenants. It has been plagued for years by leaking pipes, black mould, tropical ants, sweltering temperatures and ceilings that periodically cave in thanks to faulty heating and plumbing. Residents in the block are forced to use inhalers and even then suffer from repeated bouts of pneumonia.

Situation B is the global problem of climate change and habitat loss.

The council, in this case, is Westminster. But can you guess which of these two problems the council has formally declared to be an “emergency”? It is not the one it is responsible for solving.

As we reported this week, Westminster council has been warning leaseholders in its properties that they are on the hook for charges of £25,000 to £66,000 to fund a new, net-zero heating system. Its tenants face rocketing service charges.

Meanwhile, in Baku as one of just two G7 leaders bothering with Cop29, Keir Starmer has been repeating the usual claim that net zero will generate “cheaper bills and higher growth”.
Since ministers rarely spell out what this means in practice, it is left to the rest of us to dig into it. And Westminster’s failing heat network, the Pimlico District Heating Undertaking (PDHU), is a pretty alarming case study.

The PDHU was the UK’s first heat network, a system that pipes heat directly to users instead of relying on domestic boilers. It was originally built to pipe waste heat from Battersea Power Station under the river to homes in Pimlico, but now generates heat using three huge, centralised gas boilers. Until a few years ago the PDHU was being “celebrated” by Westminster council as a “low-carbon source of heat” that was “affordable” for the 3,000 households it serves.

Then the 2022 elections swept the Tories out of power in Westminster. Labour set about finding ways to meet a 2030 net-zero target the council had unilaterally imposed upon itself. Following recommendations by the Climate Change Committee, the Tory government enshrined in law the plan for a fifth of British homes to move off boilers and on to heat networks, because they are supposedly a “proven, cost-effective way of providing reliable, efficient, low carbon heat at a fair price” (this is not quite what the Competition and Markets Authority found when it investigated them in 2018, but never mind).

Just last month Labour ministers announced plans to build six new heat networks, including a jumbo one called “Swan” in London, which is meant to incorporate the PDHU, the Houses of Parliament and the Royal Opera House.

Unfortunately, back in real life — and this had probably been obvious to residents for years — it was becoming clear that instead of being a “celebrated” asset, the PDHU is a crumbling liability plagued by dangerous issues, such as poorly insulated pipes overheating whole buildings and repeated leaks, including a seven-year drip that is forming its own stalactites.
Tory councillors claim they were making plans to address the network’s worst problems and upgrade the rest over time. The idea was to shut off the failing parts and start giving flats their own electric boilers. If it had actually been pursued with any urgency, this might have quickly addressed the most acute problems.

But such a plan does not seem to have appealed to Labour. Instead, this year the council opened a massive consultation on revamping the whole network. Relying on analysis done by Aecom, a consultancy, it came up with a longlist of 13 options, then cut this down to a shortlist of five.

The shortlist contained several oddities. The first was that it dropped the option of installing individual boilers. Aecom had concluded that though it might be among the cheapest options upfront, the ongoing cost in the form of electricity bills would be too high. Digging into it, the Tory councillor Ed Pitt Ford, who used to work as an investment manager at Octopus Investments in a team that is now part of Octopus Energy, thought this strange. He found Aecom had included various upfront costs he thought were dubious, like the need to run boilers constantly or replace all radiators even though many are brand new, and had used an electricity price that was two to three times more than the current market rate. Aecom, for its part, stated it was using the government’s own official price forecasts. (Incidentally, shouldn’t someone ask ministers why they are telling us that a net-zero grid by 2030 will mean cheaper bills when councils are actually making investment decisions on the basis of government forecasts showing electricity prices far higher than they are now?)

The options that had made the shortlist were surprising. They all had high upfront costs and the interest rate used to value these costs was low. One was an experimental plan to use “thermal batteries” shipped on a 17-mile relay of river barges and two schemes relied on a “river source heat pump”, a technology earlier assessments had said might be “technically unviable” and might require a separate insulation project.

The council had also shortlisted the new jumbo heat network, Swan, that ministers were trumpeting. The inclusion of Swan on the basis of Aecom’s modelling “felt massaged”, says Pitt Ford. The model assumed Swan would benefit from renting out the old gas boiler building, a windfall inexplicably not included in modelling the cost of small individual boilers. Pitt Ford also spotted that Aecom, in addition to advising Westminster on the PDHU, was separately working for the government developing plans for the Swan. This seemed to him a conflict of interest.

A spokesperson for Aecom stated that its models used “the government-standard approaches… developed over more than a decade”, that Westminster is in charge of the shortlist, not Aecom, that it “has no preference, financial or other interest in PDHU connecting to Swan or any other system”, that it finished its work for Swan “earlier this year” and that “any suggestion or claim that Aecom has been conflicted during either of these projects is entirely false”.

As anyone can see, it is not necessary to be a conspiracy theorist to harbour grave doubts about this whole project. It is true, as net-zero advocates tend to argue, that the UK is full of crumbling infrastructure and that fixing this requires investment, climate or not. But sceptics are right to worry that the policy agenda is driven by grandiose, pie-in-the-sky ideology rather than humbler, slower and more practical ideas. Going flat to flat putting in electric boilers may not be exciting, but it stands a chance of addressing residents’ urgent problems quickly, eventually reducing gas consumption and sticking vaguely to the original cost estimate."
Reply


Messages In This Thread
COP 29 - by Kit Kat Chunky - 11-12-2024, 06:27 PM
RE: COP 29 - by Borin' Baggie - 11-12-2024, 06:39 PM
RE: COP 29 - by FenlandBoing - 11-12-2024, 06:42 PM
RE: COP 29 - by Borin' Baggie - 11-12-2024, 06:52 PM
RE: COP 29 - by FenlandBoing - 11-12-2024, 06:39 PM
RE: COP 29 - by Borin' Baggie - 11-12-2024, 06:40 PM
RE: COP 29 - by Kit Kat Chunky - 11-12-2024, 06:59 PM
RE: COP 29 - by Borin' Baggie - 11-12-2024, 07:12 PM
RE: COP 29 - by Kit Kat Chunky - 11-12-2024, 07:32 PM
RE: COP 29 - by man in the corner shop - 11-13-2024, 04:04 AM
RE: COP 29 - by Borin' Baggie - 11-12-2024, 09:16 PM
RE: COP 29 - by Kit Kat Chunky - 11-13-2024, 02:01 PM
RE: COP 29 - by Borin' Baggie - 11-13-2024, 02:08 PM
RE: COP 29 - by Kit Kat Chunky - 11-13-2024, 02:26 PM
RE: COP 29 - by Borin' Baggie - 11-13-2024, 02:49 PM
RE: COP 29 - by Kit Kat Chunky - 11-13-2024, 03:06 PM
RE: COP 29 - by Borin' Baggie - 11-13-2024, 03:31 PM
RE: COP 29 - by Kit Kat Chunky - 11-13-2024, 04:21 PM
RE: COP 29 - by backsidebaggie - 11-12-2024, 09:20 PM
RE: COP 29 - by Borin' Baggie - 11-12-2024, 09:57 PM
RE: COP 29 - by Protheroe - 11-13-2024, 11:43 AM
RE: COP 29 - by Borin' Baggie - 11-13-2024, 12:03 PM
RE: COP 29 - by Protheroe - 11-13-2024, 12:09 PM
RE: COP 29 - by Borin' Baggie - 11-13-2024, 12:14 PM
RE: COP 29 - by backsidebaggie - 11-12-2024, 10:41 PM
RE: COP 29 - by baggy1 - 11-13-2024, 07:29 AM
RE: COP 29 - by Protheroe - 11-13-2024, 12:51 PM
RE: COP 29 - by Borin' Baggie - 11-13-2024, 12:58 PM
RE: COP 29 - by Protheroe - 11-13-2024, 02:14 PM
RE: COP 29 - by Borin' Baggie - 11-13-2024, 07:54 PM
RE: COP 29 - by Protheroe - 11-20-2024, 08:29 PM
RE: COP 29 - by Borin' Baggie - 11-20-2024, 08:50 PM
RE: COP 29 - by man in the corner shop - 11-20-2024, 11:25 PM
RE: COP 29 - by Protheroe - 11-21-2024, 06:54 AM
RE: COP 29 - by Borin' Baggie - 11-21-2024, 08:43 AM
RE: COP 29 - by Kit Kat Chunky - 11-21-2024, 11:44 AM
RE: COP 29 - by Borin' Baggie - 11-21-2024, 12:56 PM
RE: COP 29 - by Kit Kat Chunky - 11-21-2024, 01:08 PM
RE: COP 29 - by Borin' Baggie - 11-21-2024, 01:30 PM
RE: COP 29 - by Kit Kat Chunky - 11-21-2024, 01:44 PM
RE: COP 29 - by Protheroe - 11-21-2024, 01:06 PM

Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)