11-19-2024, 12:22 AM
(This post was last modified: 11-19-2024, 12:48 AM by Borin' Baggie.)
(11-18-2024, 06:19 AM)Everything Zin Wrote:(11-17-2024, 06:32 PM)man in the corner shop Wrote: I knew it was basket case. But debt is now £18bn plus £23bn worth of repairs needed.
Still, shareholders were paid out £7bn between 1990 and 2022.
And the debt level in 1990 when it was a public utility? Zero.
Ah, privatisation and the market doing its thing.
Of course they had no debt as a public utility- they just sucked on the teat of the taxpayer. I worked for a company supplying the water companies in the 80s and they were a complete joke.
I had that same opinion on water a couple of years ago but Seven Trent deciding to pay me dividends instead of upgrading their sewage works to stop them dumping raw sewage into my local river has completely changed my mind over the last 24 months. Their primary concern as a public utility company should be to reinvest money into infrastructure, not pay shareholders. They're clearly still a complete joke, so what's the point?
(11-18-2024, 09:49 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:(11-17-2024, 08:21 PM)man in the corner shop Wrote: I agree
It seems that some services just need to be public - trains and water for example.
Water and Electricity, definitely.
BT has done well in private hands, as did TSB and a few other companies.
Jury is out on trains and buses for me. I'm reading all over the weekend how great it is that some bus routes are now coming back into public ownership, and it will give great community service. That's all well and good, but the buses, fuel, drivers etc all have to be paid for. Saying it will grow the economy is one thing, but that doesn't pay for a fleet of shiny buses today. These routes were discontinued for a reason - they were unprofitable. The way to do this is to obligate the private operators to run unprofitable routes alongside profitable routes. Don't let them "cherry pick".
BT were in the process of finalising their fibre rollout before being privatised, at t very least the competencies that now comprise Openreach should have stayed public to finalise that. Can you imagine if we'd been 20 years of the rest of the world at the point of the internet blowing up?
Bus franchising like in London (and what's due to be rolled in the West Midlands) is still privately run, just publicly managed. Buses are so much better to use in London than anywhere else in the country. Trains is an infrastructure issue more than anything but there's a real issue with absolute cowboys (First Group) fucking up again and again with the competencies that fall under them while getting away with it - see: Avanti being treated as untouchable despite being worse in every metric than their predecessor.
The energy supply market is fine being privatised, there's enough competition there. As for CEGB, our transmission side is basically regulated to function like a public sector company so I doubt there's much difference there, the upstream (generation) side though has been a complete disaster in terms of centralised energy generation investment like nuclear, gas and coal - mainly with respect to Nuclear Electric being spun out which, ironically, is now run by a subsidiary of the French public electricity company (EDF) as there's almost zero will for the private sector to invest in conventional new nuclear due to the huge CapEx requirements. Private sector investment into decentralised transmission and the Lib Dems reforms in government to stimulate private sector investment into things like wind and solar has been fine, though there's barriers to fully exploit that with connection and transmission capacity restrictions.
I really don't see the point in the state owning a bank (with the exception of an investment vehicle for infrastructure), or things like car companies.

