11-01-2024, 01:51 PM
(11-01-2024, 01:42 PM)Logic1 Wrote:(11-01-2024, 01:38 PM)Protheroe Wrote:(11-01-2024, 01:29 PM)Logic1 Wrote: What if the increase in taxes on employment, leads to firms substituting away from labour to capital? Perhaps stimulating investment instead of relying on cheap labour? This has not been mentioned by anyone.
It's been mentioned by me since 2008. Since the GFC wage suppression has enabled plenty of moribund firms barely making a margin to stay in business on the back of cheap (and formerly plentiful Labour), and just about servicing their debt.
Given that even Labour considers mass immigration to be unacceptable these days (apparently) then it's a plan of sorts. Unfortunately, as was pointed out to me last night - too many British businesses essentially spend their time selling "coffee" to each other - which makes the substitution of capital and / or higher skills / wages unlikely.
I've never really bought the zombie firm argument. Surely the zombie's would have been put out of business by now with the higher interest rates? I'm happy to concede if there is evidence to the contrary.
One other thing to note, perhaps higher interest rates, combined with higher public current and capital spending may be better for the economy, as opposed to lower interest rates pumping up the housing market?
Where have you been for the last few years? Working class people cannot afford mortgages rising to 5% let alone any higher. Higher Interest rates will only drive capital value of houses even higher, preventing even more first time buyers entering the market.
As Proth has said, if the public wants better services and infrastructure, then that should be provided. I agree with this, it is what I want. This investment is for all of society to pay for though, not just the few pockets that Thieves has attacked, such as Farmers, those with pension pots and small businesses. Load the cost on Income Tax. The less you earn, the less you pay, so that is fair.
