10-20-2024, 03:50 PM
(10-20-2024, 03:00 PM)Protheroe Wrote: I suppose it really depends on what your understanding of Palestinian land is.
I have every sympathy with those suffering the effects of settler violence, and I probably don't disagree with you much about the existence of settlements on the West Bank in principle. In practice there has never been a separate independent state for Palestinian Arabs, only forever drifting often tribal boundaries under the jackboot of the Romans, Persians, Babylonians and the Ottomans amongst others - including Jordan for a lengthy period.
Unfortunately, as I pointed out much much earlier on this thread the PA is a corrupt mess much like the ANC is now. It doesn't speak for a majority of Palestinians on the West Bank let alone in Gaza. The PA can't guarantee Israeli security, so here we are.
So what? Many modern states did not exist in their current forms one hundred years ago. This is goalpost shifting towards the Zionist canard of there being no such place as Palestine and therefore no such people as Palestinians. Except that Palestine did exist as a recognised territory specifically when it was placed under the British mandate. Besides this, in the modern era, Palestine is recognised as a state by 146 of the 193 member states of the United Nations.
I would say it is more that Israel can't guarantee the PA security as opposed to the converse. After all, it is Israeli citizens who are being allowed free reign by a clearly corrupt Israeli state to terrorise Palestinians in the West Bank.

