I suppose it really depends on what your understanding of Palestinian land is.
I have every sympathy with those suffering the effects of settler violence, and I probably don't disagree with you much about the existence of settlements on the West Bank in principle. In practice there has never been a separate independent state for Palestinian Arabs, only forever drifting often tribal boundaries under the jackboot of the Romans, Persians, Babylonians and the Ottomans amongst others - including Jordan for a lengthy period.
Unfortunately, as I pointed out much much earlier on this thread the PA is a corrupt mess much like the ANC is now. It doesn't speak for a majority of Palestinians on the West Bank let alone in Gaza. The PA can't guarantee Israeli security, so here we are.
I have every sympathy with those suffering the effects of settler violence, and I probably don't disagree with you much about the existence of settlements on the West Bank in principle. In practice there has never been a separate independent state for Palestinian Arabs, only forever drifting often tribal boundaries under the jackboot of the Romans, Persians, Babylonians and the Ottomans amongst others - including Jordan for a lengthy period.
Unfortunately, as I pointed out much much earlier on this thread the PA is a corrupt mess much like the ANC is now. It doesn't speak for a majority of Palestinians on the West Bank let alone in Gaza. The PA can't guarantee Israeli security, so here we are.

