10-16-2024, 10:42 AM
(10-16-2024, 10:13 AM)Josh1873 Wrote:I agree with you Josh and it's the rules that I'm at odds with, that and the fact that the FA chose the option, they didn't have to.(10-16-2024, 09:56 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote:(10-16-2024, 09:50 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: Other than the 'manager's should be of the nationality of the country they're managing' argument, what other reasons are there to appoint an English manager over a foreign manager?
This English coach progression argument is bollocks, too. We're a multi-cultural country, and I'm actually proud of that. All coaches should be given an equal opportunity in the English pyramid, regardless of their nationality.
It's 2024, FFS.
That's fine but raises the same question, why not apply it to the players?
If we are saying get a foreign manager in because no English ones are any good, why not apply same rule to left back?
Because that's not the point of international football - it's not within the rules. Tbh it's already a bit of a piss take with how tenuous the links some players use to play for a nation!
I really don't want to come across as thick or condescending, but appointing a foreign manager is within the rules (I disagree with the rule, BTW), so I don't see the issues. If the FA believe Tuchal is a far better candidate than any current English incumbent then they are correct to appoint him. For what it's worth I genuinely don't think there are any valid Englishmen for the job. Potter, arguably. But that's about it.
I have no issue with Tuchel, he's applied for the job and got it, good on him.
At the end of the day, I think a bit of perspective is needed and tempering a bit of the language (in general, not you Josh). People are moaning, that's it, and they are entltled to do so. Doesn't make them racist, xenophobic or stupid, or any of the other accusations being muted, they are little more than disgruntled in all honesty.
Genuine question. If it is just about the rules and the rules were changed to allow players of different nationalities, would the "best man for the job" approach still apply?

