10-14-2024, 01:49 PM
(This post was last modified: 10-14-2024, 02:48 PM by backsidebaggie.)
(10-14-2024, 11:21 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:(10-13-2024, 10:42 AM)Cuzer Wrote: The 116-112 card against Bivol was an absolute disgrace
A lot of pressure on Whittaker now as it certainly looks to all like he was after a way out
Cuzer
Completely agree, there is simply no way Beterbiev won that fight 8 rounds to 4. No way. I had the first 3 rounds going to Bivol, the next 3 to Beterbiev, then the next 3 to Bivol again, although I could see a 2-1 there instead. So 6-3/5-4 after 9. Then you could argue a 3-0 Beterbiev in the final 3 rounds, I personally had it as 2-1. So for me, 7-5 Bivol but absolutely could see a 6-6 or a 7-5 to Beterbiev, if you preferred him hitting Bivol's gloves the whole fight. 8-4 is just too lopsided for what a close spectacle it was.
The problem with the scoring system and how subjective it is, is that what most people are talking about is the scorecard and the judges. Not the actual boxing. It's the problem boxing has had for years, and just doesn't get out of it's own way with shit like this.
So much wrong there.
Beterbiev didn’t hit the gloves the whole night. The clean punch stats were very similar. Beterbiev won close rounds on ring generalship and effective aggression. Bivols superior technical boxing was too intermittent to win the close rounds in the judges eyes… he circled the ring too much, and 10 second flurries three times in a round didn’t cut it.
8-4 isn’t too lobsided as boxing scoring is round by round, as I keep explaining. You admit 7-5 is reasonable, yet one round difference to that is a disgrace? lol.
You’ve even answered your own question, by saying judging is subjective… which it is! Hence, taking into account the four factors they judge each round on, the subjectivity literally means there will be variation on the weight put on those factors. Nothing disgraceful about putting more weight into effective aggression and ring control. It’s part of the scoring in EACH round.
Good article by Bunce in the independent agreeing with the decision. The sky commentators bias has duped people IMO. That and people not understanding 8-4 can be a close fight.

