09-30-2024, 03:02 PM
(09-30-2024, 08:09 AM)Protheroe Wrote:(09-30-2024, 07:48 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: What does ‘winning’ actually look like? The most decadent opinions are from those who are treating the deaths of hundreds, thousands of people like General Haig in Blackadder Goes Fourth, just something to sweep up and pop in the bin. Whilst they live safely thousands of miles away and think not being able to afford private school is a sacrifice.
Good question. The ultimate answer is Israel not being permanently under existential threat. The more likely answer is denuding the military capability and prestige of Iran and it's proxies enough to bring another temporary period of peace. Given that Hezbollah is most likely now being run by people who two weeks ago weren't trusted with a pager I sense that's progress.
As for your latter point... see another thread.
You haven't answered the question because you've completely removed the Palestinian people from your answer. Has Dekka said, just people to sweep up and put in the bin.
Again, you overlook that the Palestinian resistance movement predated any Iranian movement. You also overlook that even before 7th October, over 240 Palestinians had been killed on the West Bank, including 9 people killed by settlers:
https://reliefweb.int/report/occupied-pa...ear-record
There will be no peace until there a just settlement for the Palestinian people. The Israeli state thought they had defanged the PLO and PFLP, instead Hamas and Hezbollah were created instead.

