02-10-2019, 01:40 PM
(02-10-2019, 08:53 AM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote:(02-10-2019, 12:25 AM)Dreamkiller Wrote: Let me give a genuinely honest opinion. Firstly, I have to get the usual disclaimer out of the way. We lost fair and square, and nothing the ref did had any effect on the result. Just wanted to make that clear.And are you"getting better", as DM said post match? Apart from the fact that I get nervous watching on TV, and was terrified every time you attacked... I don't remember stoke making any real chances. One good cross behind our defence which Dawson saw off.
I really don’t think the ref was a homer. In the first half I’d say he was penalising us for stuff that he was letting you get away with, mostly niggly little things, but annoying all the same. This has pretty much happened in every game I’ve seen this season. I’m quite prepared to accept that this might be a natural unconscious bias on my part, so long as you guys can accept that your own views might just be coming from the same place.
On the handball, it happened very quickly, I’ve not seen a replay, and I couldn’t really say one way or the other whether it should have been given. We’d have missed the penalty anyway, so no harm done.
On the Livermore tackle, it was at the other end of the pitch to me, and while from a distance it looked potentially like a nasty challenge, I’m not sure that Vokes didn’t milk it a bit.
Equally, Livermore actually received a fair amount of applause from quite a few Stokies when he just got up and made nothing out of a lunging challenge that might have seen Joe Allen in a bit of trouble if Livermore had done what 90% of players would have done. Instead though, he just got up, gave Allen a hug and got on with it. Credit to him.
My biggest gripe with the ref is that he didn’t book your keeper towards the end of the match. There were a couple of minutes to go when you got a goal kick. The ball was kicked to Johnstone who deliberately kicked it away. A photographer then threw the ball to him and Johnstone again kicked it away. The ref ran towards him, urging him to get on with it, but he’d seen exactly what had happened and should have got the yellow card out for something as blatant as that.
I’ve no problem with your players wasting time, and boy did they waste a lot. I’d be disappointed if our players hadn’t done the same if the situation was reversed. But it grinds my gears that refs don’t take action when time wasting is done so openly. A homer ref would certainly have done so.
Them’s my onions.
Even your supersub (!) never got near the goal.
We rarely test any keeper, so no change there. There were actually a number of really good crosses put in by Edwards, but every single one of them was picked off by your defence - by good crosses I mean they were put into the danger zone just out of reach of your keeper.
There are small signs of improvement generally but it's all small margin stuff. We probably need three or four new players in key positions to get the best out of the other players. They're not all utter shit, but they're lacking focal points and leaders.
Ironically, after a couple of years where he's been more or less in the wilderness, the player we're missing the most is Charlie Adam who's out injured at the moment. He has the nous we're lacking, can get a boot in and leave it there long enough to hurt, and can spray the long balls about which suits the full backs getting forward which Jones' sides need.
As for West Brom, I said at half time that the only way I could see us scoring was through an Edwards cross, or by picking something up by closing down your keeper. Butland's kicking isn't great, but if I was an Albion fan I'd be shitting it everytime Johnstone takes a back pass.

