08-29-2024, 08:19 PM
(08-29-2024, 03:14 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:(08-29-2024, 09:49 AM)fuzzbox Wrote: Despite being a committed remainer, I'm not sure that conflating brexiteers and the far right is correct or helpful.I didn’t confuse the two things I gave Brexit as an example of when people choose to believe in something no matter what information or facts given to the contrary. The purity of the cause is more important than reality of the situation, and no solution will be good enough to live up to the cause they have taken up.
I get that you don't want to reason with people that you don't think will change their beliefs. However, by your inaccurate and derogatory labelling, I can't help feeling that you may be similar!
If that's the case, how can you be expected to understand their motivations? Following on from that, isn't it inevitable they will never be influenced by your arguments and so, as you say, will never change their minds?
If i got labelled racist for advocating tighter immigration or brexit, I doubt l'd listen to their arguments. My over-riding emotion would be anger. If enough people closed me down and insulted me, I may seek solace somewhere else that i felt i was respected and listened to...
With regards to right wing opinions that Robinson advocates, again you can put the facts to those who agree with him that disprove what he argues but belief will inevitably trump this with those who choose to believe.
If you want to get personal that’s up to you but at the very beginning of my post I said there is a discussion to be had about immigration and integration. “Yes there are concerns around immigration and imo more importantly integration and checks on the character of those arriving”, these are hardly the words to suggest I’m against having the conversation.
The point was two fold, one we have been listening and reacting as a country to people’s concerns on immigration for at least a decade. Farage, Robinson, Tice, The Mail, Telegraph, GB News and an entire think tank industry bankrolled by dubious backers have been shouting long and hard their position on the subject. They and those that support their views are not marginalised, we have had a Conservative Party pandering and appeasing those voices for years.
The second point is, problems with immigration won’t be solved from the hard left or hard right politically, they can only ever be solved by moderates, through compromise, pragmatism, education and conversation between people willing to listen. Sadly those are the voices currently been marginalised on SM but as we’ve seen since the riots not by most people who were against the rhetoric Robinson and co expouse.
On second thoughts, you might be right!

