05-18-2019, 09:12 AM
In truth he got one decision massively wrong - the Holgate penalty was as clear a penalty as you will see.
Unfortunately so was the one that was given.
I have changed my mind on the Gayle second yellow booking, at the time and watching it in real time, thought it merited a yellow, having watched it back before the second leg, think Gayle was doing enough not to get the second yellow and he certainly wasn't helped by the antics of the Villa goalkeeper.
Gayle's throw in booking might be controversial, but he had been warned just a few minutes before. Not only that on this message board before a ball was kicked there was a thread on the officials for the play off semi final. It was mentioned that Scott was a stickler for time wasting, so I was aware that any scent of time wasting was going to be clamped down on by this ref.
Does make me think why the same ref doesn't get to officiate both games. If time wasting was Scott's eccentricity, then surely both teams as an away side should be subject to it.
Unfortunately so was the one that was given.
I have changed my mind on the Gayle second yellow booking, at the time and watching it in real time, thought it merited a yellow, having watched it back before the second leg, think Gayle was doing enough not to get the second yellow and he certainly wasn't helped by the antics of the Villa goalkeeper.
Gayle's throw in booking might be controversial, but he had been warned just a few minutes before. Not only that on this message board before a ball was kicked there was a thread on the officials for the play off semi final. It was mentioned that Scott was a stickler for time wasting, so I was aware that any scent of time wasting was going to be clamped down on by this ref.
Does make me think why the same ref doesn't get to officiate both games. If time wasting was Scott's eccentricity, then surely both teams as an away side should be subject to it.


