(08-01-2024, 05:36 PM)Pontificator Wrote:(08-01-2024, 03:53 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:(08-01-2024, 02:04 PM)Squid Wrote:(08-01-2024, 12:53 PM)Protheroe Wrote:(08-01-2024, 12:47 PM)Squid Wrote: Hamas aren't the entirety of the Palestinian population and they haven't existed for the vast majority of those 70+ years, nor are they in power in the West Bank or occupied Golan Heights.
The Israeli occupation of Gaza, the West Bank and East Jerusalem has been ruled as illegal by the international criminal court.
That's all true Squid. But even before Hamas, Israel's neighbours attempted several times to destroy the Jewish State.
And let's not forget - that previous aggression (which was also illegal FWIW) is the only reason Israel occupies Gaza, the West Bank and the Golan Heights.
I'd say the 1948 Nakba which started all these problems was pretty aggressive too.
But that all distracts from the major point: Israel cannot kill its way to security. There is no magical number of Palestinians it can slaughter to solve its problems and demographics and geography are not in their favour, either.
Why so many "supporters" of Israel can't see this is puzzling.
It all goes back to their suffering at the hands of The Nazis.
I don't condone the actions of either side, but it's clear that history shows they can't live in peace alongside each other.
That is pretty ignorant. Pogroms are centuries old. The Holocaust was the "never again" moment, until 7th October and history repeated it self
If I lived in Israel I would never be at peace whilst HAMAS, Hezbollah and their murdering. raping, kidnapping and rocket firing fanatics roam free. Israel don't need peace lessons from anyone
I actually think you are right that Israel don't need lessons from Hamas and Hezbollah.
Let's go through your list of actions:
Murdering - 30,000+ dead. I posted an article a few pages back where US Doctors saw numerous Palestinian youngsters with bullet wounds to the head - that is undeniably murder.
Raping - Widely documented as happening to Palestinian detanees male and female in Israeli dentention centres and prominent members of the Israeli government oppose any punishment for it.
Kidnapping- arbitrary mass detention is state-sponsored kidnapping. Here's a quote from the UN Office of the High Commission on Human Rights:
"Those taken into custody in Gaza, as well as in Israel, have been generally held in prolonged secret
and incommunicado detention, with no information provided to their families on their fate or whereabouts, in many cases for weeks or months, raising serious concerns of enforced
disappearance."
You can read the report in full here: https://www.ohchr.org/sites/default/file...lities.pdf
Rocket firing- Israel have been firing an array of munitions upon Gaza, so no further guidance needed there.
I haven't seen Hamas or Hezbollah endlessly posing with dead women's underwear, so again, the IDF doesn't need lessons from anyone else on doing that:
https://forward.com/opinion/598153/israe...za-photos/
I actually think Israel does need the outside world to intervene, as opposed to just writing a blank cheque, because they currently look like a nation pressing the self-destruct button.

