02-09-2019, 10:24 PM
(This post was last modified: 02-09-2019, 10:24 PM by albion_pigeon.)
(02-09-2019, 10:13 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote:(02-09-2019, 08:37 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:(02-09-2019, 08:03 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote:(02-09-2019, 07:48 PM)KratosBaggie Wrote:(02-09-2019, 07:46 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Jones is clearly a good manager as shown by his work at Luton, but his lack of adaptability will cost him.
Stubbornly believes in his own system when the players aren't suited to it.
Some blame has to go to the Stoke directors who appointed him as should have been obvious from any chats pre-appointment that this wasn't going to work!
Why do managers have blind faith to a system or tactic. The first job Jones should be doing is judging the players and finding a system to get the best out the squad. Not shoe horn them into a cute idea.
Because if you do this you will never change to a system that you want to play. Which will make you as a manager uncomfortable which in turn will affect the players.
Better to start with the way you intend to go. Chances are managers move on from clubs, more often by getting the sack, better to get the sack pursuing a style of football you believe in than do something you don't.
Does that work in practice? If they continually play a style and formation that doesn’t bring results, what has that achieved? Absolutely nothing as a manager. Any decent manager plays to the strengths of the players he has available, and over time if he / she get results you can afford the luxury of evolving the squads to players that can play your preferred way.
For example asking the old Wimbledon to play from the get go like Man City would end in tears extremely quickly.
It's a fair point Derek.
But I think this concept of a slow evolution is easier to say than do. Usually when you start to make big accommodations to your football beliefs it is very difficult to get it back to where you want it to be.
Certainly Guardiola didn't make too many concessions to his way of doing things in his first season at City, even though it meant his first trophy less season in football management. I suppose it depends on how much trust you have in your employers not to panic if things do not go well to start with.
And if Stoke employed Jones not knowing anything about how he approached football and how his approach may compliment Stoke's current squad then more fool them. But I would assume they did, and possibly part of the strategy was that they were willing to accept that this appointment might mean that the rest of this season would be a write off, and a period of time for Jones to assess his squad and find out who and who can not adapt to his methods.
Guardiola started with a team full of world class players.
I think one approach that might work at one level might not necessarily work at another.
I love to see English managers from lower leagues do well and obviously it's early days. But maybe Jones has come in with the exact same mindset at Luton where he was managing a bunch of lads who are working class by trade. He's now managing a bunch of working class lads who've been living the high life in the papers for the last few years. Different approach needed.
You could say the same about us but bid dave knows the players and club well already so he's a step up in that respect.

