05-02-2024, 11:02 AM
(05-02-2024, 10:26 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:(05-02-2024, 10:10 AM)Ossian Wrote:(05-02-2024, 08:26 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: To this day I am yet to hear a legitimate argument for what made Jeremy Corbyn unelectable, especially given what the Tories have come up with since.
He did, Ted.
Part of electability is perception and Corbyn was never going to get past that. We (the UK electorate that is) will, now and again, swing the pendulum over to a few degrees left of centre; usually as a reaction to a sustained period of Tory failure. The only real exception post-war was Attlee's landslide in '45.
It's a lesson the left need to learn. There are still plenty of so-called Labour supporters ready to trash the legacy of the last Labour government; some - even more preposterous - who seem to genuinely belIeve that the centrists and social democrats deny Labour election wins by diluting the purity of the message and not just getting on board.
I admire Attlee for his sustained levels of year-on-year achievement; Wilson and Blair because they won consistently, then delivered. If you can't win, what use are you? If Starmer wins, come whenever, he will have made a start towards being good Labour leader. The only alternative is handing the Tories another go.
2024, and it's 50 years since Harold Wilson won his fourth and final election. In that 50 years only one Labour leader has won an election, and he won three. That's how the odds are stacked and Labour either play the game as it is or they lose.
Don't disagree with any of that bar the first line.
It's no wonder we are where we are when the likes of Johnson and Truss are perceived electable and a bloke who has consistently advocated for the improvement of conditions for the most needy and vulnerable in our society was not.
Tories play politics on easy mode. Cameron only won in 2015 because Miliband had the gall to eat a sandwich.
And if Labour had had any notion of what was good for them they’d have chosen David Miliband as leader instead of Ed after he cosied up to the unions. They might well have won an election off the back of that alone.

