03-29-2024, 09:31 AM
(03-29-2024, 08:41 AM)Protheroe Wrote:(03-29-2024, 08:09 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: The idea that capitalism has lifted billions out of extreme poverty is one that is widely stated, but those making it rarely have to justify it.
If they did I think they would struggle to do so.
In the UK for example, if it had been left to the capitalists then high levels of absolute poverty would have lasted far longer than they did.
There is no reason to believe that this would be any less true globally.
The adoption of markets by an otherwise awful regime has pretty much eradicated absolute poverty in China in a generation or two. How much more evidence do you need?
In the UK government used to recognise what it was for in the enablement and effective regulation of markets. As it is, crony capitalism and the nationalisation of risk threatens to condemn us all to tax servitude.
Grinding poverty exists only these days in states that eschew markets, property rights and the rule of law. Tell me I'm wrong?
(03-28-2024, 11:59 PM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: Sure. All the problems it appears to solve also inevitably produce a new set as a consequence. Ad infinitum (look it up)
Really? "All the problems"?
So working fewer hours than ever, being better housed, educated, fed and clothed than ever - largely due to the magic of markets has thrown up what particular First World Problems in its place?
Externalties? Definitely. But all have been, are, or could be overcome with effective regulation and incentivisation.
You're simplistic in your reasoning Proth. You could easily say that China's authoritarian system of Govt, allows them to ensure a fairer distribution of wealth is a factor that reduces poverty as the adoption of market forces. In post war USSR it could be argued that there was a similar reduction in poverty, without the introduction of market forces.
And let's be honest neither China nor USSR should be held up as good adverts in the fight to eradicate poverty.
You keep asserting that property alleviates poverty, how so? Property denies those who do not own it the right to resource which can be a cause of poverty.

