(02-07-2024, 04:19 PM)Jerry Wrote:(02-07-2024, 04:16 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:The stats do not show this, which is why after a player on film clips the scout will go and watch them before the club buys a player.(02-07-2024, 04:04 PM)Jerry Wrote:(02-07-2024, 03:59 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:(02-07-2024, 03:52 PM)Jerry Wrote: The actual data provided as discussed is flawed. Still respect your view.
Just out of interest, mate. How is it flawed?
Because it is only measuring interactions ie headed challenges, tackles, passes etc, it is not measuring reading of the game, being in position to stop the pass in the first place, quality of passing, presence on the pitch, wanting the ball etc which is all part of a players game which is not measured by stats.
All of that can be inferred through things like interceptions (reading of the game), progressive passes or pass completion (quality of passing), admittedly I don't know what presence on the pitch means, wanting the ball (receptions). Lurker quotes all of the above on a semi-regular basis.
Beat me to it TM.
Jerry - You are of course right, a little bit. Stats are only any good when used in context. All of the things you mention above can, as TM suggested be inferred through the use of the stats provided. By the way I only use a small handful of the available data as its more common place and easy to understand.
Frankly, the majority of scouting is now done remotely. Looking at data and videos. Brentford and Brighton have incredible set ups in this regard. They then, of course, watch a player in person and try and get a measure of their personality and character.
Whether or not we (football fans) like it. The game is data driven, scientific in its approach to tactics and training and games are largely won/lost in the fine margins. It may not be romantic, but its sadly the reality.
"IMO of course..."

