10-25-2023, 04:25 PM
Which goes back to my original question, what is the Israeli government's end game? Nobody that thinks what Israel is doing with respect to Gaza is unequivocally right is answering this, and you can't keep ignoring that not having an end game is a serious issue.
Flattening northern Gaza and hoping that Hamas go away is not a plan to reach an end game. Scrutinising what appears to be the Israeli government's strategy is not challenging their right to self defence, it's saying that what they're doing isn't a coherent strategy and if they want to react in self defence in a coherent way they need to think of something else as hope doesn't cut it.
"But Israel’s security chiefs know the goal of destroying Hamas is probably beyond their reach. Hamas has a political base and extensive external support from Iran."
- Key line for Proth that he keeps ignoring. This is very unlikely to destroy Hamas. Hoping they go away isn't a strategy, it's delusion. You want to get rid of Hamas? You need to displace them.
Flattening northern Gaza and hoping that Hamas go away is not a plan to reach an end game. Scrutinising what appears to be the Israeli government's strategy is not challenging their right to self defence, it's saying that what they're doing isn't a coherent strategy and if they want to react in self defence in a coherent way they need to think of something else as hope doesn't cut it.
"But Israel’s security chiefs know the goal of destroying Hamas is probably beyond their reach. Hamas has a political base and extensive external support from Iran."
- Key line for Proth that he keeps ignoring. This is very unlikely to destroy Hamas. Hoping they go away isn't a strategy, it's delusion. You want to get rid of Hamas? You need to displace them.

