10-01-2023, 08:58 AM
Much as have an irrational delight in any Liverpool defeat, last nights game highlighted the inadequacy of this system.
I think the Jones red card was the right decision, but was it a clear and obvious error. Nowhere near for me. What's the point of this guideline if it's never applied.
On Jotas red card, the second yellow was probably deserved and he was an idiot for making that tackle knowing he was 9n a yellow. But the first was ridiculous. Not being able to review yellow cards is a problem if they can lead to red cards is an issue, especially when straight red cards are reviewed.
The offside goal is something else and to my mind potentially sinister. The explanation last night is plausible but stinks of incompetence. But when you see things like this happens it makes you think that the ability for var to manipulate results is there.
I would take offside decisions away from var, and give the power back to the linesman.
Actually I would scrap var altogether.
I think the Jones red card was the right decision, but was it a clear and obvious error. Nowhere near for me. What's the point of this guideline if it's never applied.
On Jotas red card, the second yellow was probably deserved and he was an idiot for making that tackle knowing he was 9n a yellow. But the first was ridiculous. Not being able to review yellow cards is a problem if they can lead to red cards is an issue, especially when straight red cards are reviewed.
The offside goal is something else and to my mind potentially sinister. The explanation last night is plausible but stinks of incompetence. But when you see things like this happens it makes you think that the ability for var to manipulate results is there.
I would take offside decisions away from var, and give the power back to the linesman.
Actually I would scrap var altogether.

