09-10-2023, 12:37 PM
(This post was last modified: 09-10-2023, 12:41 PM by Borin' Baggie.)
(09-10-2023, 12:12 PM)Protheroe Wrote:(09-10-2023, 11:56 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:(09-10-2023, 11:52 AM)Tom Joad Wrote:(09-10-2023, 11:41 AM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote:(09-10-2023, 09:20 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: I intended to let this lie as we all appear convinced to our own opinion. But yesterday I needed a quick visit to a couple of our maintenance sites so I jumped in Mrs Joad's car rather than the van. I left the site at Bourneville en route for between Lichfield/ Sutton Coldfield, A38 all the way, through the city centre (I'm not normally allowed) in tunnels. Never needed to change down, 4th and 5th all the way, no lights, roundabouts and I guess, little pollution. One side of the city to the other in about 35 minutes. This week I'll need to make the same journey but with a van full of gear. It will involve a detour to avoid ULEZ, round the ring road and queueing at traffic lights, filters, roundabouts. An hours drive. Now I am now toying with the idea of simply paying the charge and making up with more time working. Also, if I'd chosen to go in my relatives 6ltr AMG, we would be allowed in the ULEZ zone anyway. None of this makes sense to me.You make sensible points which need response from decision makers.
But the overriding issue is, do we want to breathe in clean air?
The rest is details.
Except I maintain the air is cleaner by driving through the tunnels, straight through town in 5th gear, than all that queuing on the middle ring road on the outskirts. It's a badly thought out, box ticking policy. IMO.
Except the report that UoB produced (that Proth misrepresented) disagrees, reduced in the CAZ and no increased effect outside the CAZ after just 7 months.
I know people working on this at the uni and every time they bring it up they say it's empirically working.
There's no reduction in PM2.5 - the pollutant with the greatest health effects in the CAZ. You've made your own misrepresentation there.
So how is it "empirically working" if it's failing to reduce the most most harmful pollutant?
Because there was a measured reduction in one of the key target pollutants that was assessed to be statistically significant after just 7 months with no increase outside the area of the CAZ and a non-significant decrease in PM. That is empirical data that backs up the measures working in reducing NOx.
Do you want to take your misinterpretation of the report up with the authors?

