09-07-2023, 08:00 PM
(09-07-2023, 06:38 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:(09-07-2023, 06:11 PM)Protheroe Wrote: The Lib Dems are still toxic to a huge part of the Labour Party. They’d also act as a brake on Labour’s growth agenda with the opportunistic anti development credentials that they’ll be rolling out all over southern England next year.
As for your examples of coalition, I don’t think anyone on here is quite old enough to remember all but the last lot which oversaw the “austerity” most loath. Perhaps for someone as chronically picky as you I ought to have said no cultural history in living memory.
And in German & Dutch terms, the stability of government under Mutti & Rutti has given way to economic disaster in one and potential economic crisis in the other. What a fine legacy.
Labour have Matt Western in their shadow cabinet, if you want to get onto the topic of "anti development credentials".
The same faction of the Labour party that consider the Lib Dems toxic also don't like Starmer and call him Keith for some reason, do you want me to point you in the direction of canvassing data in the recent by-elections to see what Labour-Lib Dem swing voters think though and why the Lib Dems have been so effective in squeezing voters? Also, the last set of local elections.
The coalition between 2010-2015 was more politically stable than the subsequent 8 years has been, shall we also ask people whether they think 2010-2015 was better or worse than 2015 onwards? Also, on the topic of cherry picking, you can't just say that we don't have a history of coalitions and then ignore one because you don't like that it's been brought up. There's also the postwar Lib-Lab pact and the Tory-National coalition as well from the 1960s onwards, do they also not count?
And if your contention of coalitions is their instability, why are you dismissing the extremely stable Dutch and German governments. Merkel's mistakes shadow Thatcher's mistakes in the 1980s in prioritising short term gains over long-term infrastructure development so I'm a bit confused as to why you'd bring that up against FPTP, especially given your love of Thatcher. As for Rutte, since 2010 the Dutch economy shat on ours while they moved towards modernising the economic structures and improving quality of life and empowering economic freedoms - I prefer pretty much everything over the Netherlands than the UK except for the food and the Dutch economy is a model the UK government should be pursuing to replicate.
I don’t know the man but I do hope Matt Western’s nickname is “Spaghetti”.


