08-22-2023, 01:42 PM
(08-22-2023, 01:31 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote:The first two are factual, the comparison to Guardiola, well, he's overrated anyway!(08-22-2023, 01:01 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: Carlos is a young manager who's still learning his trade and, so far, making a decent fist of it, doesn't mean he's impervious to criticism. If he's got anything about him, which I'm sure he has, then his biggest critic will not be anyone on this bored, but will in fact be himself!
Genuine criticism and calling for him to be sacked are two very different things.
No-one's saying he's beyond criticism, but if you regard saying "what's he ever done apart from getting Huddersfield from being in the relegation zone to the play-off final and then getting us from the relegation zone nearly into the play-offs?" and saying he thinks he's Guardiola as "genuine criticism" then that's up to you. I don't.
His managerial record so far speaks for itself and prior to that he was a highly-regarded coach. There are lengthy videos espousing his style of play and managerial philosophies. When he left Huddersfield they dropped like a stone, so it seems reasonable to conclude that them reaching the play-off final was primarily down to him. He's in an extremely difficult situation where the club will sell any of our players at the drop of hat without any guarantee of them being replaced. He still currently has a 50+% win record with us, so it doesn't seem to be asking much for people to cut him some slack rather than sniping.

