(08-17-2023, 10:19 AM)baggy1 Wrote: I think you may be looking at it the wrong way Proth, you are basically taking a failing system and carrying on with that rhetoric until it disappears down the plughole by every decreasing circles. The current way of thinking is clearly broken - tax individual and corporate earnings to pay for the infrastructure that provides a framework for the individuals and corporations to operate. The problem is that there is ever higher spending on the infrastructure which requires ever higher taxation - I think we both agree that can't continue so there has to be an alternative approach.
This is where we disagree - your view is to reduce taxation which will stimulate investments, create jobs and therefore increase taxation revenue. Simply put like that it sounds ok, the problem comes from the corporations not reinvesting in either jobs or salaries and hiving off ever growing profits to shareholders and other beneficial owners. This has been the model for a few decades now and we are not improving as a country (UK PLC) which leads me to believe that system has failed.
My view is that we have to a) look to raise funds from other sources such as creating nationalised industries for example green industry whereby any future profits go into the coffers of the revenue which is longer term but doesn't solve the immediate problem, and b) renationalise the industries that are either costing UK PLC in subsidies or simply not an industry that has competition (water, railways) and collect the profits from those to increase the income side of the P&L.
There are other measures that need to be looked into, we have to wean the NHS off the use of private healthcare to plug the gap. You have referred to the cost of the NHS in the past but ignore the inflated amounts that go straight through to private providers. That needs to reviewed and a future saving by building the actual capacity of the NHS rather than keep cutting both wages and services.
We need to look at a national housebuilding plan through a government agency funded directly rather than relying on house builders that will sit on land because it isn't profitable enough.
There are many ways to build for the future which will be painful now but unfortunately the current model has failed and that situation isn't going to get any better I'm afraid, we will be working in ever decreasing circles unless we change the direction soon.
We agree, absolutely (I think) on the central point - which is that the system is failing.
We agree, absolutely (I think) on the approaching perfect storm of an aging population / higher dependency ratio / aging infrastructure / climate transition and what that means for taxation, borrowing and crucial decisions about the role of the state.
I doubt we disagree much about any of the optimal outcomes either - just the way of getting there.
I think something else we can agree on is that our current political leaders on all sides are not up to the challenges we face and worse still just can't be honest about them.
Let's look at taxation; markets which drive economic growth are all about incentives and at the moment those incentives are being eroded on a daily basis. Our taxation system is far too skewed towards employment income and corporate profits. Both employment incomes and corporate profits represent the type of activity that is to be encouraged - but increases in the marginal rates of tax, the introduction of new taxes like the Dividend Tax and applying that to dividend remunerated directors, the vicious effects of fiscal drag, not applying NI to working pensioners, reducing capital allowances for investment all serve to create economic 'bads' - like "quiet quitting", like sclerotic productivity because there's no incentive to invest in tech, like the chilling effects of ridiculous marginal tax rates faced by graduates if they get a pay rise which bumps them into higher or top rates of tax, like people actually getting a job rather than starting a business.
How much better to would it be to reorientate our tax system away from income and profits and more towards assets? Particularly unearned wealth. Land Value Tax is the least avoidable and most equitable of all taxes - it'd also assist with increasing housing starts (see later). The trillions tied up in UK property also needs to be tapped one way of the other, after all - those of us with slugs of equity have benefitted from the Derek Hardballs approach to planning and "free money" for far too long. In the few years we've lived in this house its "value" has risen by 60%. This increase cost me nothing. This increase involved zero risk. This increase benefits from a complete exemption from CGT, whereas the increases in value of my other risk assets including my businesses are all exposed to taxation on exit. How on Earth is that equitable to those being charged huge marginal rates on income with little hope of ever being able to even afford a modest home?
Given that the railway is de facto nationalised at the moment anyway my main concern is where on Earth the money comes from for investment. Government has already said that fares won't rise more that 9% in January and the network is already massively subsidised by the taxpayer - a huge middle class bung from the working classes. All I can see under the Tories is a residualisation of the network back to the chronic underinvestment of the BR days.
As for the other Utilities - the governments key role ought to be in enabling development of generation and direct investment in transmission. I was in Suffolk last week, which voted Green at the locals - you would not believe the hostility to Sizewell C and planned Solar Farms over there - all led by second homeowners from London (where they probably also vote Green or Red - wankers of the highest order this lot). The key criterion here is the liberalisation of planning which segues nicely into housing.
Just liberalise planning. Liberalise planning to the extent that Dekka lies in front of the bulldozer (I'll drive). Subject sites with consent for housing development with incrementally increasing Land Value Tax to encourage development (see earlier). With the end of the era of "free money" we've missed the boat on selling housing bonds for social housing development - I can't for the life of me understand why we didn't do something so simple even John Clancy thought of it, and so beneficial in so many ways to occupiers, local authority / HA developers and investors.
On health the NHS needs to be reoriented from a national sickness service based on hospitals to a national health service grounded on early intervention and health education in the community. Some fucking hope. I've waxed lyrical about funding before, no one agrees with me here or more broadly in the nation so let's just leave that. However I do believe that those of us who can afford it ought to be incentivised to go private to take pressure off the NHS. I avoid paying BIK on my family's PMI by using a simple and legal accounting trick. I shouldn't have to. Most people on PAYE don't have the choice. It is utterly ridiculous to both pay your contribution towards the NHS via taxation, then be taxed again based on the value of employer PMI premiums so you can opt out of NHS treatment.
Nor is there anything intrinsically wrong in the NHS using private services - particularly when those services offer treatment in the evenings and at weekends which are far more convenient for working people (so the NHS can concentrate on the core business of older people). I'm currently receiving some diagnostic tests and treatment from the Priory. They see me on a Saturday morning at the exact appointed time, I get an espresso, a comfortable seat, muzak in reception and service with a smile. All healthcare ought to be like that.
And the Triple Lock on pensions needs to go.
And anyone with more than modest assets needs to really take a look in the mirror if they expect the state to look after them in their old age.

