(08-03-2023, 09:44 AM)Protheroe Wrote:(08-03-2023, 09:42 AM)baggy1 Wrote:(08-03-2023, 09:31 AM)Protheroe Wrote:(08-03-2023, 08:34 AM)baggy1 Wrote: I'm asking a simple question to get understanding - do you think that the tax revenues will be larger than the subsidies given to the oil companies?
I don't know for certain and neither do you.
All I can say is that the OBR forecast tax receipts over the six-year period 2022/23 to 2027/28 will average £8.6bn, up from an average of £0.8 billion over the six years to 2021/22. This, of course, does not take into account the Corporation Tax, VAT, Employers NI, Business Rates etc receipts from those companies servicing the oil and gas industry nor the PAYE, NI and consumption taxes from c250,000 people employed in the UK oil and gas industry.
In the light of those numbers the £20bn provided in subsidies to the whole fossil fuel industry in the UK since 2015 (according to The Guardian - other sources suggest far less) doesn't seem a particularly bad investment.
We are going to get oil and gas from somewhere for several decades yet, so - again it would seem bizarre to destroy our own industry whilst exporting cash and emissions. Again.
Two points come out of that
You don't know, and,
Could you apply those statistics to the coal industry in the 80s then?
Hang on.
Let's not overlook an average of £8.6bn A YEAR. Without taking into account the £billions in the other taxes I described, which you have ignored.
2023-24 Receipts alone are forecast at £10.6bn.
Let's stick to that rather than whataboutery for the moment, eh?
Just for clarity, is that for the whole of the UK oil industry or just in relation to the licences that are being issued?
I know that you don't like to address some facts that don't fit with your argument but I'm simply trying to get the information and understanding about the new licences that are being issued.
You refer to tax revenues from these installations - is it correct that they will not be operational, to the extent that they can sell oil, for a couple of decades?
If the above is the case, how will that improve the UK's fuel security? I could get the argument if that was alongside the other greener initiatives, but as BB has highlighted it will be 'instead of' rather than 'as well as'.
Also this theory that the North Sea oil will simply go into the coffers of the UK reserves alone. Again this appears to be nonsense as the companies that are drilling are global companies and will sell to the highest bidder or it will go into the global market at a set rate.
So from what I can see these licences won't bring in tax receipts, apart from employment taxes, for up to 30 years whilst we are subsidising them in the meantime. That doesn't make much sense to me, and completely blows the lie that we will make ourselves more protected from global price fluctuations.
I haven't said anything about the whole industry, I'm just trying to understand why we would expand it at this point.

