08-02-2023, 03:35 PM
(This post was last modified: 08-02-2023, 03:44 PM by Borin' Baggie.)
(08-02-2023, 02:52 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Lot's of hindsight, wishful thinking and dismissive contentions there.
In a country that's got used to handout after handout you will have one hell of a political battle on your hands at the point the cost becomes clear. No matter how noble and scientifically cogent the cause.
I'm not arguing against the road to net zero. I'm pointing out the practical impediments that are likely to become insurmountable due to the cost, and where that burden falls. There will be some very difficult political decisions to make.
What you're doing is fearmongering. None of what I said is magical fairy dust, all of it falls into either being something other Western European countries have done (with comparable or better quality of life to the UK) or are (costed) Lib Dem policy proposals. Meanwhile, what you're arguing is to repeat the exact same mistakes of the 1980s and not learn from the fallout of an oil and gas crisis (as France did, successfully) and properly electrifying, in-turn repeating the OPEC crisis of the 1970s or the recent energy price crisis when our reliance on fossil fuels comes home to roost. How much has not following through on building AGR reactors in the 1980s because of CapEx concerns cost us in the medium term? A lot. Community heat schemes (Denmark), rail electrification and capacity expansion (started in the UK back in the bloody 1930s before being abandoned), new build regulations on heating and power (Norway, and proposed for the UK by the Lib Dems back in 2015), solar power covering (India of all places is doing this with canals, right now). These aren't hypotheticals or small scale research plans, these are all manageable and deployable at scale with current technologies and all of it improves quality of life and access to energy and should be plowed ahead with over the next 25 years.
As for the costs, keeping with any level of reliance on oil and gas will cost us more in the long run and current LCOEs are suggesting it would cost more in the short run than oversupplying renewables - what you want is also stupidly expensive. That's not to mention the huge costs associated with not doing enough, getting to net zero is the cheaper option and a simple surface level analysis of infrastructure and social costs of not getting there spells that out in black and white. Just plan out how you will deal with water irrigation, flooding, rising sea levels, storms, reduced arable land and dealing with hundreds of millions to billions of displaced people and get back to me on what is actually insurmountable due to cost. Net zero is the cheap way out, quite frankly - not to mention is the only practical means to decouple ourselves from global market instability.
The problem is purely dire press coverage on energy, bad actors only presenting half the argument to push their narratives and chronic short-termism.
I'll ask you this, do you know how much money the British taxpayer is on hook for in dealing with already existing North Sea oil infrastructure up to 2030? I'll give you a clue, you can build 5 Hornsea One-sized offshore wind farms (6GW of installed wind grid capacity) for it.


