(07-29-2023, 05:04 PM)TartanRug Wrote:(07-29-2023, 04:47 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: Surprised that people think we should be getting north of 5m for Palmer.
No criticism of him, but he has less than a season of chpionship appearances under his belt. Nor is he seen as having the potential of Trafford and to a lesser extent Griffiths.
I would expect a minimum of £8m for Griffiths, but Palmer if we get a guaranteed 3m for him with the potential for more, that seems to me a fair fee.
Whether we should be accepting the deal is another matter altogether, and very much depends on how it allows us to shape the squad, and the confidence we have in the other keepers in the squad.
Like any deal it could be a disaster.
Bur it could also be a masterstroke, allowing us to bring extra quality and giving the opportunity to Griffiths to realise his potential and be a player we could sell for 20m next summer.
Or it could be a bit meh.
Do you really think we'll see a penny of this (pathetic) fee? It will go towards paying off the debt.
Correct
Palmer is worth way more than 3m to us. Griffiths is a good keeper but he's young, isn't as good as stopper as Palmer, but more importantly he doesn't organise the defence in the same way that Palmer does. If you want to be competitive then you should want the best players.
Palmer was statistically one of, if not the best, keeper in the league last season.
What this says is that we would rather gamble having a keeper that has shown himself to be a rock at this level for the sake of 3 million quid and the hope that a promising youngster (assuming he stays) will be able to carry us from the back this season.
Losing Palmer doesn't just weaken us in net, it also weakens an already shaky defence. It shows we have no interest in being competitive.

