(07-23-2023, 03:38 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I think it's clear which one I consider good defending and which one I consider, praying for luck and hoping to get away with it with a good 'keeper.
It is no coincidence Man City's defence got better with a more conventional defender in Ruben Dias, though of course he's good enough to do the modern stuff well too.
Give me a Bartley over an Ajayi every single time, play a structured, behind the ball line and make sure they know how to defend. That's how we punched above our weight for so long. It's how to make a team do better than the sum of its parts.
Aye, and ain't that depressing! I don't rate either - not at all to be clear! Not even a little! It's why I was so upset about the Dara sale at £7M as he should be worth twice that and enough to sign a proper leader. The thing with centre backs unlike anywhere else on the field, is you can get away with a poor one if the other is a leader. Best example of all, villa. McGrath was so good he made Shaun Teale look like a top class defender. His wife thought so anyway, she was trying to force moves to Everton, Liverpool, Man Utd! Then McGrath got injured and Teale's value plummeted faster than Tulip bulbs in 1637. Unfortunately, we have 2 Shaun Teales and nothing like a McGrath.

