07-22-2023, 12:43 PM
(07-21-2023, 12:13 PM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: arf
think I'll bin off my SMWS membership, despite living next door to the Vaults. They've been bottling a lot of underaged shite blend-filler recently. Looked at a 9 yr old Ben Nevis 2nd fill oloroso at £59 but it's 67%. I had a Ben Nevis from them at 8yrs old 2nd fill sherry at 66% and it was just swamped by the alcohol. All well and good bottling only at cask strength if its right for the whisky but they seem to be bottling out of desperation at the minute.
Also the Vaults caters to tourist groups rather than locals and isn't worth the fee on its own.
The alcohol strength is cause it's the strength on the cask when bottled - it has nowt to do with the quality of the spirits per se. The "industry standard" is to reduce to 63.5% abv at cask filling but that's not mandatory - but it does lead to relatively low cask strength after maturation for most bottlings up to 20 year old (say 57 - 58% abv).
However, I do agree that a lot of stuff from SMWS I have bought recently has not been great and the finishing of ex bourbon casks in sherry casks is neither fish nor fowl. So, disappointing. The annual membership fee is negligible I reckons but you pays yer money....
As an aside, the whisky industry has gone bonkers for investment in bottles - if you are paying tens of thousands for a Macallan, you are not going to drink it - you are buying the bottle and brand name. It may as well be cold tea inside.

