07-08-2023, 06:05 PM
(This post was last modified: 07-08-2023, 06:10 PM by Borin' Baggie.)
That tends to happen when instead of reading what has been put you instead opt to read what you want to read as a convenient means to build up a strawman to attack instead.
Do you genuinely believe your cakeism, or is it a coping mechanism to avoid admitting that being rigidly ideological is irrational? We have a deficit, fact. We need to eliminate that deficit. We do not have natural resources to cover spending gaps as we did in the 1980s and 1990s. Wage growth is stagnant and declining in real terms so the capacity to raise taxes from that is out the question. Economic growth is stagnant so increasing receipts via that isn't happening. We have an aging population with more people becoming economically inactive as well as burdening state spending on pensions and healthcare. The practicalities of cutting tax are out of the question as there's zero capacity to cost them into the budget. The scope for public sector cuts is zero owing to budgets being frozen outside of the NHS and the state pension and it being politically impossible to cut those two. What is more liberal, raising taxes to cover the operational government deficit as a means to tighten fiscal conditions or borrowing to cover it? I've mentioned abolishing employees NI and folding that income tax rates to ensure that income outside of that scope (like pensions) is included as means to close the gap but you had a tantrum over that. Do you want us to turn into Spain or something? Or do you want the government to dream up another millennial labour tax instead to cover it if we're on about who's a "moneygrabbing statist"?
As for the "tipping point": fuel duty cut, business rates relief, income tax rates (not thresholds, rates). Are you factoring in those changes to your hypothesis?
Do you genuinely believe your cakeism, or is it a coping mechanism to avoid admitting that being rigidly ideological is irrational? We have a deficit, fact. We need to eliminate that deficit. We do not have natural resources to cover spending gaps as we did in the 1980s and 1990s. Wage growth is stagnant and declining in real terms so the capacity to raise taxes from that is out the question. Economic growth is stagnant so increasing receipts via that isn't happening. We have an aging population with more people becoming economically inactive as well as burdening state spending on pensions and healthcare. The practicalities of cutting tax are out of the question as there's zero capacity to cost them into the budget. The scope for public sector cuts is zero owing to budgets being frozen outside of the NHS and the state pension and it being politically impossible to cut those two. What is more liberal, raising taxes to cover the operational government deficit as a means to tighten fiscal conditions or borrowing to cover it? I've mentioned abolishing employees NI and folding that income tax rates to ensure that income outside of that scope (like pensions) is included as means to close the gap but you had a tantrum over that. Do you want us to turn into Spain or something? Or do you want the government to dream up another millennial labour tax instead to cover it if we're on about who's a "moneygrabbing statist"?
As for the "tipping point": fuel duty cut, business rates relief, income tax rates (not thresholds, rates). Are you factoring in those changes to your hypothesis?

