07-07-2023, 04:49 PM
(07-07-2023, 03:54 PM)Protheroe Wrote:(07-07-2023, 12:58 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:(07-07-2023, 10:51 AM)Protheroe Wrote:(07-07-2023, 09:35 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: The very fact that taxes need to go up to enable fiscal tightening and cover day-to-day expenditure but the government won't do it kind of indicates that they won't do it to reduce the amount of money in the economy either.
They could also abolish employees NI and fold it into income tax, should raise around £11bn per annum, but they won't.
As I posted in another thread, the huge tax rises already implemented are altering firms' and individuals' behaviour already.
You will simply not get more blood out of the stone.
The *only* way embedded inflation has ever been defeated is by means of an employment recession. I cannot understand why this fact escapes so many people - particularly our politicians on all sides.
The BoE and the Treasury's economic competence is shot. They encouraged the behaviour that led us here, didn't act quickly enough when it was obvious inflation was building and now have to overreact as a consequence. The attention is on mortgages, but the aim of the policy will also be on corporate borrowings - I know of one PE-backed firm whose borrowings were at base +7% in 2019, goodness only knows where they'll be when they refinance later this year.
Income tax and VAT rises are pull money out of the economy in the same way interest rate rises do by incentivising saving (especially tax-wrapped savings) in turn reducing business and consumer spending which would trigger a recession.
Tax receipts also need to go up to tighten government fiscal conditions as what we have isn't sustainable, preferably by means that are more difficult to avoid than corporation tax. Unfortunately this isn't the 1980s anymore and we can't rely on natural resources to cover the shortfall in the Exchequer as Thatcher relied on. We need to go back to a Gladstonian line of thinking and accept we need to pay more tax.
As the Treasury isn't yielding what it thought it would from the enormous tax increases already implemented, what on Earth makes you think further increases in tax would work?
Personally I'm delighted the great British public are acting rationally and avoiding paying for the mess created by the BoE and Treasury.
It's like you have an inability to read what has actually been written.
Raising corporation tax is ineffective, that is the only tax that has gone up in nominal terms. We have data that shows that raising it or cutting it doesn't appear to actually raise the amount as a percentage of GDP. The two taxes that there is data that indicates a link are NIC and income tax (don't even need to increase the rates, just abolish employee NICs and fold into income tax, calculated at £11bn), but they're only increasing in line with fiscal drag and not in nominal terms. Then there's things like the reduction in revenue generated from fuel duty owing to the cut in fuel duty and the reduced fuel usage, as fuel duty isn't a rate but a fixed quantity relative to the carbon content of the fuel.
It's not about "further" tax increases, it's about the reality of taxes need to be raised to eliminate the deficit coupled with the government being too scared to raise the taxes that will make a difference. The government are engaged in fiscal cakeism.

