It's The Ashes (again)

[Tom Joad]

I think what's most annoying about being 2-0 down is that we are so close to the Aussies (on balance). First Test was a narrow defeat, but brought upon ourselves by wasting an opportunity to bat them out of the game and then failing to deal with the tail. Note that Jimmy hardly bowled towards the end, even though we were effectively a bowler down with Moeen's finger.

Second Test was close because of Stokes' superhero performance, but we didn't need to be that far behind. First innings batting was largely poor. Bowling bouncers for long periods basically put Jimmy out of the game (see above). Could we have saved crucial runs by taking the new ball and bowling properly at their tail-enders? It just seemed muddle-headed and self-destructive, but the power was clear to see when the guys got angry.

Positives so far:
Josh Tongue - a young bowler who is quick and has time to get quicker. Potts maybe won't achieve the same pace, Robinson bowls like a much older man and will get slower with his build - Tongue is important. Great start for him.
Ben Duckett - pleased to see him getting runs against a strong bowling attack. He was the sacrificial victim as a junior member of a squad which was way off the rails back in 2017-18, and seems to have been tainted by that reputation.
Stuart Broad - is on fire. He always turns it on for the Ashes. I wish it didn't take anger to make him play like this.
Ben Stokes - well we know what he can do, and he's done more of it this weekend.

Negatives:
Cronyism - debatable whether Anderson should even have played at Edgbaston. After that performance he should have been replaced by Woakes for Lords. Moeen was also a ridiculous choice, his finger issues have been going on since about 2018, which is why he likes the shorter formats. Crawley got some runs, but still doesn't look like a Test batsman. Jury's still out on him.
Stokes' knee - this guy is walking wounded. He could barely run during the run chase yesterday. Bowling 12 overs straight off (largely because Anderson's 78mph bouncers weren't going to achieve much) could have a big influence on the rest of the series.
Tactics - there's a bravado about everything England do, whether it works or not. A determination not to mix things up, so if it isn't working they'll just go harder at it. Situations get out of control in a Test match and you have to be flexible in your response. I don't see much of that from Baz'n'Ben. And persistent short-pitched bowling will kill the game, as it did to a large extent in the 80s.
Approach - unless I misunderstood him, Stokes appeared to say that the players were free to do what they thought, without fear of criticism. For me, Stokes could have had a word with some of his batsmen in the first innings, got them to calm down and play with patience, as he did himself. Seems strange to me that this is apparently contrary to the ethos.
Joe Root - and this is the big one. Of all the players Joe Root, best batsman in the world, seems to be the one who feels pressured into not playing his normal game. Stacks of runs in the 1st test, but the 2nd passed him by. Joe Root not scoring runs is like Jimmy Anderson being on the field but not taking the new ball. Just not right. But Joe has years ahead of him, unlike Jimmy. He needs to find the right balance, or maybe just ride out Bazball and wait for common sense to break out (I give it 2 years max).

Good post. I would add to the negatives, Harry Brook's crazy dismissal and the done to death Foulkes/Bairstow situation. I also feel both games were closer than many would have us believe and both could have gone either way. Now, with added edge we go to Headingley, The closest ground there is to an Edgbaston type atmosphere. We have tried everything to get tickets but sadly, only the official ticket touts-Viagogo and co- have any to spare and even they are odds and ends at silly money. If England can get one back, I would really fancy us to win another.