05-01-2019, 07:27 AM
(04-30-2019, 12:45 PM)hudds Wrote:(04-30-2019, 07:20 AM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: Just me who was a bit let down? An hour of poorly lit random battles scenes before (IMO) an unsatisfactory ending?
The night king has been built as the Big Bad for 8 seasons and just....got stabbed? Easily? Without ever saying anything or changing his facial expression during the whole series. I hope we find out more about his backstory and motivations before the end of the series otherwise that's a wasted character. Bran as the 3 eyed raven did feck all, Jon did feck all, daenerys, Tyrion, Sansa all did feck all during the episode.
Maybe an unpopular opinion but I was looking forward to the big payoff fight scene with the night king and had thought that one of Jon or Dany was going to sacrifice themselves to beat him.
Some bits were good, the arya library scene carried a lot of tension and lyanna mormont's scene was pretty cool. At least Beric's (who is a great character) death has some dramatic weight to save arya.
Maybe I'll like it more on a rewatch
Me too. I'm not a huge fan of the series but some of it was compelling. I don't like the dragons and supernatural stuff - it would have stood on its own without but that's how the books were written. I can make a case for my critique but that's not the point here.
Last night I thought it had some good scenes but the lighting made it difficult to "read" a lot of what was going on (or why) and it was overlong and felt like it was going through the motions (to be fair, lot of "big action" films feel that way, which it why I tend to avoid them). I stayed with it but was dozing off. Felt "rushed" at the end. It could really have done with separate episodes.
Thought it was just me who came away from the episode a little disappointed.
My concern with the cramming it into 6 episodes was that we’d lose the storylines, plot twists and character depth which made the first few seasons so compelling and instead with it’s ever growing popularity as a series, these would get substituted for expensive effects and big action scenes which this whole episode was.
It was compelling TV, with some beautiful direction, some brilliant suspense and some excellent battle scenes but overall I came away from it disappointed. As you’ve said TNK has been built up as the eternal bad guy for 8 seasons, only to be killed so easily and with the first plan they came up with feels a disservice to his character... and the fact that so many people survived the battle under frankly impossible odds made a mockery of the whole thing. Quite how Brianne, Sam, Jamie, Grey Worm, everyone in the crypt are all still alive is laughable.
Also I’m relatively sure Pardew was advising them on a tactical master plan for that battle, and some of our defenders under Graeme Jones were making decisions for characters.
An enjoyable 80 minutes of TV or so for sure, but I don’t think it did the last 8 seasons justice.


