(02-15-2023, 05:58 PM)MassDebater Wrote:(02-15-2023, 04:35 PM)fuzzbox Wrote: What's all this 'we' rubbish?
It's got nothing to do with me. If it goes back to wherever, I'm betting the equivalent 'me' over there won't get any benefit from it either.
One rich person took it off another rich person who stole it off another. None of them really considers it 'our' property, despite the fact that 'we' probably paid for it.
Typical misdirection of politicians in both places, distracting us by waving the flag in one hand, whilst taking our money with the other.
a country where the ruling set unashamedly steal billions and the millions who live in poverty happily wave the flag for such hollow victories is actually quite sad.
As I said earlier though it was gifted to us. So out of all the stealers, we never stole it.
As for their caste system that transcends racism. I'm not even sure what racism towards your own race is just because they're born poor or whatever it's based on.
Again, who is 'us' and 'we' ? I can tell you it's not me or you. Try buying something with it or using it as collateral for a new house!
So a government is pointing at a fictional bogeyman, while ignoring real problems. But then I can think of countries much closer to home that do that....
But to be honest, I don't see how you can link the injustice of the caste system to a diamond. Two separate issues, surely? But then, I don't give a flying what India says about the UK in order to distract from their own government shenanigans.
The British Empire wasn't fair and we were taught a hugely bias version of it, but then I can't think of a single powerful country that didn't pursue their own power at the expense of others. But again, British empire isn't 'me' or 'we' or 'us' and most of the wars weren't fought on our behalf. Christ, most of our forefathers were living short, impoverished lives in squalid factories at the time, so I take no blame or credit for it.
But, as it happens I would take issue with blaming the partition completely on the British Government. That's demonstrably false. It's fairly clear that opponents of partition who believed that Muslims, Sikhs and Hindus all had a common culture were wrong*. There never was a common culture, it was a totalitarian fantasy. The British Empire on the other hand was, as always, predictably pragmatic. The British Empire weren't blameless, but there were far bigger villains in the room, but that ruins the Great Indian narrative.
*Just my opinion, other opinions may vary!

