02-12-2023, 01:03 PM
(02-12-2023, 12:15 PM)BurleyBaggie Wrote: I think we need to stop the disrespect of Button. Two things are true 1. His confidence is absolutely shot, I know in my tiny none relevant world how that feels as a keeper at a lowly amateur level. You’re scared of getting a shot, scared of a corner. Everything become ten times harder and you think rather than reacting. 2. He’s 34 now, his skills are on the decline. Add these together and you have fatal mix.
However, the guy has played over 350 professional games, more relevant is he played decent matches for us at SJs understudy in the league and cup.
So while I agree he’s completely out of form and not at his peak, I don’t think we should be so critical of the man and footballer - I absolutely think he should be dropped but I just don’t like the vilification.
The biggest issue with Button is just how mentally weak he is
He’s spent most of his career in the top 2 divisions as a back-up keeper where there’s very little pressure. In the few games he acted as a stand in for us under Johnstone he was fine, to the point where some fans called for him to be selected ahead of Johnstone.
Being a number 1 however is much tougher. There is pressure and expectation that simply isn’t there on a second choice. If you come in as backup and drop a clanger it doesn’t “matter” as much as you’ll be seen as being a little rusty, or “only backup… the best keepers won’t sign to warm a bench”
When you’re first choice, you have to perform. Button simply doesn’t have the resilience to cope with that level of expectation, and as we saw on Friday night, he just can’t bounce back from a big mistake.
Palmer and Griffith need to be 1 and 2 and Button just needs to be left on the bench at best and paid off in the summer.


