02-02-2023, 07:18 PM
(02-02-2023, 06:54 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:(02-02-2023, 01:17 PM)SausEggBaton Wrote: Think a lot of this angst and dislike against Rugby stems from folk not enjoying the game while in PE at school (if your school taught Rugby or PE of course), ect, and perhaps being roughed up by the bigger boys, or not being willing to get involved.
Used to play Rugby for the school team (which was grant maintained, don't you know), we had 4 or 5 County players, so we were pretty good.
Therefore, I believe someones latter life perspective of Rugby depends on how they were brought up with it. Particularly, if you were dragged up, oop north, Yorkshire & Lancashire - you'd most certainly have an affiliacation with some form of Rugby.
To have an instant irrational dislike for Rugby though, having never played the game, and just being "football, football, football", seems a little closed minded to me, it's one of England's oldest national games and originated in Rugby, Warwickshire, alledgedly. Yes, yes, they're called Egg chasers as a friendly moniker but that should be left there as that. It's really a game of skill, tactics and strength, pretty much like football.
And I also agree with baggienick68, if you don't like Rugby, don't watch it, and don't tell everyone you hate Rugby with no real substanance of an arguement.
I went to one of those grant-maintained school. I played rugby reluctantly for 7 years. It annoyed me that there was no soccer played at all - I believe that's still the case now it's a private school. So the "anti-soccer" mindset of rugby union is confirmed by that. I don't believe all 15 players need much in the way of ball playing skills, just fitness, physique and a willingness to crunch into the opposition with wild abandon. I played in the scrum (being a fat boy in my youth). I never once kicked the ball in a match during my entire playing career. I probably passed the ball successfully to a team mate less than a dozen times. Chase, tackle, push in the scrum, jump in the line-out, chase, tackle etc. Couldn't see the point.
I don't mind people playing rugby, same as I don't mind people playing golf. But rugby players need to stop telling me how shit soccer is and golfers need to stop boring me with their weekend escapades on the links. And most of all, accept that I don't have to care about your obsessions.
Went to a "rugby focused" secondary school as well, in a "rugby town". We still played football though, and we played football at breaktime and lunchtime. Also played club rugby as a teenager over football. There absolutely is skill to it, hand-eye coordination, agility, balance, timing drop kicks etc. Even timing tackles and tackle technique are skills.
I'd also say most if not all of my rugby playing mates at least watched football (fair few played football as kids at junior school and early secondary school, like myself) as well though, and most played cricket. Said school was council-run at the time and is now an "Academy" though, not sure about the private school or public school kids nearby.


