11-21-2022, 06:02 PM
(11-21-2022, 05:48 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:(11-21-2022, 04:32 PM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote:(11-21-2022, 04:24 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:(11-21-2022, 03:09 PM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote:(11-21-2022, 03:06 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: *when playing weaker teams.
Southgate deserves more praise than he gets but he’s just not a good in game manager. Both the WC semi and then Euro final were lost in very similar circumstances.
Beating Iran, USA and Wales should be well within what he does best. If we have to overcome a side as good as/stronger than us, I have little faith.
What a crock of absolute bollocks.
What in this is wrong?
The idea that we’ve only had good runs at the last two tournaments because the opposition were all shit. Also that the wins were somehow in spite of him but the Croatia and Italy defeats were all down to him.
If we get past France this year it’ll no doubt be because Benzema was out injured or some other load of drivel.
I haven’t said we played shit teams, and I’ve said Southgate deserves more praise than he gets - have you even read my first post?
FWIW I think Southgate has done a brilliant job in making the England team likeable again, and I think the work he’s done behind the scenes will never truly be appreciated. In terms of his impact on the National set-up he’s up there as one of the most innovative we’ve ever seen.
As a coach however, I’m yet to be convinced. It’s difficult to argue against the fact we have had very favourable runs in his previous two tournaments. Germany were a strong opposition but were not the Germany of old, and with Low on the way out, it was a very transitional side, played at home. On the night we were very impressive and deserved the win.
Unfortunately the semi with Croatia and the final with Italy had the same pattern. We took an early lead and dropped off. We didn’t engage, and when both Dalic and Mancini made changes, we stuck with more of the same and ended up losing to sides that were more than beatable. Mancini in particular ran rings around Southgate on the night.
So to clarify, I think Southgate has done well on and off the field in the main, but in two of the 3 games he’s faced opposition on a par with us at tournaments we’ve been outmanoeuvred IMO.
If we’re counting Croatia 2018 then why not Croatia 2021, which we won?

