11-01-2022, 04:29 PM
(11-01-2022, 04:07 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:(11-01-2022, 03:53 PM)Protheroe Wrote: The Commonwealth Fund Survey ranks 11 developed nations' Healthcare performance. The NHS is usually near to the top in how it runs the bureaucracy (hurrah) but always in the bottom three when it comes to healthcare outcomes. Depending on your perspective (producer or consumer) this is either a good or a bad result.
Going back to my foot (and P Major's ear) we were dealt with IMMEDIATELY - there was literally no wait. I was presented with a bill which I'll claim back via insurance. What's not to like?
There is great work by the NHS everyday. Just not enough of it. Far too often the organisation exists to serve itself rather than us. It's not alone in that, don't get me on to the crap I've had to put up with from Royal Mail in the last two days...
I'll ask the obvious question. What about those who can't afford either insurance or the bill that is presented to them upon treatment?
That's the thing. Other than Proth's extremely spurious "people will demand more output" that I don't believe as the evidence doesn't suggest that, I've yet to see or hear a reason why the method of payment would make a difference. There is zero point in shifting from a Beveridge model system to a Bismarck model system, and vice versa, with universal healthcare. Either you pay in via general taxation or you pay in via an effective tax (and general taxation in all the good Bismarck model countries, because that's how Treasury spending is done - it's never ringfenced). What's the difference? The Treasury is still paying for it.
Fixing the inherent structural issues in the NHS has absolutely nothing to do with the funding model, they're not present in other Beveridge model countries like Denmark, Norway, Sweden, Finland, France, Italy etc so what lick of difference will it make? As far as I'm concerned it's purely ideological nonsense.

