09-25-2022, 11:55 AM
(09-25-2022, 10:41 AM)KRO Wrote:(09-25-2022, 08:52 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: There are a few aspects of this which stand out for me.
For me, this takes the unpopular "Mankad" to a new level - not punishing a non-striking batter for cheating by backing up too far, but deliberately deceiving them. Does Sharma practice this move? To put it in football terms, it's like praising a player for "drawing a foul", or the old Bergkamp favourite "I felt a touch so I went down".
- The captain definitely gave Sharma the nod to do it. Worried that they might not get the wicket any other way, desperate to win, despite being 2-0 up in the series.
- The England batter wasn't trying to steal an advantage, her bat was grounded behind the crease as the bowler went into her "delivery stride".
- The bowler clearly intended to deceive the batter into thinking she'd released the ball, wasn't even looking down the wicket as she shaped up to "bowl".
- The self-congratulatory hysterics of the Indian team were insulting.
- The joyous crowd scenes were unsurprising and rather charmless.
- The England women behaved with rather more dignity than I could have mustered in similar circumstances. Imagine someone doing that to Stuart Broad?
- The Indian press was full of jubilation, describing it as a "brilliant run-out".
And it says all we need to know about the post-Colonial chip on the Indian shoulder. Sad that our great game is now owned lock, stock and barrel by them.
I’ve played and always watched the ball be bowled, she strolled down the wicket oblivious to what was happening. I’ve no problem with it. Stay in your bloody crease.
Not true, KRO, Dean watched the feet go into the stride before she left her ground. Non-striking batters don't watch the ball out of the bowler's hand, they're looking for where it might be hit and whether there's a run. This kind of dismissal is to punish batters who steal a lot of ground as the bowler bowls. Not intended as an opportunity for a bowler to pretend to bowl, just to catch an unwary batter out. Dean wasn't trying to cheat, in my opinion Sharma was. Do we want all footballers to be like Greasy Grealish, famed for winning free kicks? Do we want bowlers to be good at pretending to release the ball? The game's gone, Tom!
You've played cricket. Have you ever even seen a Mankad situation? If so, how often? I never did. This can't be defended by any reasonable argument that acknowledges sportsmanship as a concept.

