04-10-2019, 09:30 AM
(04-10-2019, 09:10 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:All of it is subjective. I never hated Pardew in any way as much as I did Pulis. In fact the away game near the near the end of Pulis's reign at Southampton was possibly the worse game I've ever witnessed as a fan. If we get up this year, which is still a 1 in 4 chance, then the argument might be what a great job West Brom have done coming straight back. Only hindsight a few years down the lne can make sense of it all.(04-10-2019, 08:47 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: Success and failure can be narrow margins and whilst we were getting the results under Pulis to people outside the club it looked rosy. We knew it was short termist and destined to end in tears as well as being excruciating to be part of.
The years under him, to my mind, is the big issue. Remember Pardew, as hopeless as he was, took over a bunch of players who only knew how to score from set pieces and many who never crossed the half way line. The way Rondon has shone at Newcastle emphasises the way he was under-used.
You are arguing that the squad he inherited was better before he arrived for it to be ravaged. It wasn’t that’s my argument. It was an extremely weak squad that had no resale value whatsoever. Yes we wasted millions and TP is culpable for relegation as are the owners and those that have left. You won’t get any argument there but the point remains and it isn’t subjective we were in a tailspin of poor decisions and poor appoint to before TP arrived. He was a sticking plaster solution to a festering wound and over the long term the plaster was causing just as much infection as the original wound was.
Luckily we bought in Pardew who got the knife out amputated the problem.

