08-30-2022, 05:21 PM
(08-30-2022, 05:03 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:(08-30-2022, 04:53 PM)Banbury Baggie Wrote: Can someone please explain the difference between paying for and playing Thomas-Asante vs playing Cleary (who is ours)?I'm with you on this Banbury. Cleary should have had more minutes in the league this season. Every game we haven't won has been crying out for fresh legs and all we get is Phillips or Reach.
B T-A is young, untested, and when tested only scores a few goals (according to some on here). Surely Cleary could come in and score goals with our set up we have now? In relation to Cleary I hear all of the 'loan him out' and other such comments so he gets experience....is B T-A really that more experienced that we are prepared to use him until Dike regains/retails fitness?
Sorry for this view, but it seems like we are cutting off our nose to spite our face here.
This kid is a few years older which is the only difference really. Don't get me wrong, I'm all for looking at the lower leagues and hope we are unearthing a hidden gem, but it's a coin toss basically.
I'm a huge fan of Cleary as everyone knows and I agree he should have been on the bench more and given minutes when surrounded by first team players. Thats my frustration. He's played with fringe players in Carabo and hasn't had the luxury of having proper ammunition alongside him.
I think what people forget though is Cleary has just turned 18. BTA is 23 and has played league football a fair bit over the last few years, and by the looks of it, he is now progressing nicely as a result.
Its a huge step up and Cleary really is raw. I'm surprised Salford didn't ask for him on loan in return. I would have Cleary on the bench all day long but he probably needs to be loaned out if Bruce doesn't fancy him yet. I'd rather that than U23s as he has already proven he can bang them in at that level.

