08-01-2022, 08:45 PM
(This post was last modified: 08-01-2022, 08:46 PM by HawkingsHalfpint.)
Wow, this grew legs!
The way I see it, we don't often get it right mid-season anyway. And often our decision has little bearing on the outcome afterwards...
Mel = brought in and we survived. Some would have (why I don't know, when it was mainly down to the seniors we survived), but we didn't keep him anyway.
Pardew = failed. Got rid.
Shan = didn't quite make it. We didn't keep him.
Allardyce = failed. Opinion split on whether we would have kept him, wasn't our choice to make anyway.
Bruce = failed.
So it seems to me that the players (or more likely a million other associated reasons such as their condition, confidence, attitude... even who the hell they even are) have the biggest bearing when we replace mid-season. Not necessarily the chump in charge.
So whether or not Bruce failed or succeeded in his objective last year, he's still in a job. And whatever the objectives are of that job, then yes of course he only has a limited time to achieve them. I would totally agree that it's more than fair that if his season goes the same way Val's does, so does his tenure. Just a little early to start talking about that after one away draw so far this season.
The way I see it, we don't often get it right mid-season anyway. And often our decision has little bearing on the outcome afterwards...
Mel = brought in and we survived. Some would have (why I don't know, when it was mainly down to the seniors we survived), but we didn't keep him anyway.
Pardew = failed. Got rid.
Shan = didn't quite make it. We didn't keep him.
Allardyce = failed. Opinion split on whether we would have kept him, wasn't our choice to make anyway.
Bruce = failed.
So it seems to me that the players (or more likely a million other associated reasons such as their condition, confidence, attitude... even who the hell they even are) have the biggest bearing when we replace mid-season. Not necessarily the chump in charge.
So whether or not Bruce failed or succeeded in his objective last year, he's still in a job. And whatever the objectives are of that job, then yes of course he only has a limited time to achieve them. I would totally agree that it's more than fair that if his season goes the same way Val's does, so does his tenure. Just a little early to start talking about that after one away draw so far this season.


