(06-15-2022, 03:03 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Ted, a centre back that is "better suited to a back three" isn't a centre back, he's just a footballing fraud. Three at the back needs two ball players, therefore you look for these players elsewhere in the squad IMO. I noticed big Sam Field was in the left CB spot of a three for QPR at times towards the end of the season, for instance, as he did for us. Playing a third ordinary defender and standard (or sub-standard) full backs just leaves you short of creativity and goal threat. Why do people yearn for this negative formation?
Bruce is going to play a back four, according to all the journos. If he keeps Bartley and gets rid of Kipre and Bryan (both at least 5 years younger) without even seeing them play, it will prove that he favours old soldiers. The same if he doesn't play O'Shea.
I mean, that's completely wrong but fair enough. To start with, some of the most attacking sides in Europe play with three central defenders and advanced wing backs.
What I think we will agree on is that if it's a back four, the ideal set up would be O'Shea plus one (for me preferably Clarke). O'Shea is a good ball player, the very early part of last season when we were good, we relied a lot on his ability to carry the ball into midfield. We missed him badly when he was injured.

