06-12-2022, 12:53 PM
(06-12-2022, 12:07 PM)KratosBaggie Wrote:(06-12-2022, 12:00 PM)MassDebater Wrote:(06-12-2022, 11:46 AM)KratosBaggie Wrote: It should be banned.
The riders may well accept the risk, but what about their families? Is it acceptable to leave a young child without their father, a mother to lose her son, in the name of sport?
No.
What about parachuting? Bungie jumping? Wild Water swimming? Documentary film making in the Amazon? Being a War correspondent? heck just being someone who likes to shop at expensive places could get you mugged and stabbed. Driving in a regular car on a motorway is a dangerous thing to do.
I'm not a biker, but as said I know a few who are. the guy I know who raced on the TT was explaining the safety features of the racing suit he has got, it is basically an all round air bag that inflates when tolerances are exceeded. His had to fire the other week during an event when some junior rider hit him and he went off at about 100mph. Barely a scratch on him, he was just a bit sore and stiff the next day, but the suit did cost a good few hundred to get reset and re-gassed. The equipment the racers have is phenomenal.
I guess you make a valid point. I've no idea what possess people to jump out of planes or tall structures all in the name of adrenaline. But it is their choice. What are the fatality rates with those activities? I'm guessing it's much lower than the fatality rate of the Isle of Man TT, but I'm assuming, so willing to stand down here!
5 deaths in a weekend is excessive and proves the event is not safe in its current format. Why put people in a situation where it's likely they will lose their lives?
I understand your point, but in life there is a risk of death, however unlikely, in almost any situation. Commuting to work tomorrow could be your last commute due to being involved in an accident. I play cricket, and I could die after being hit in the head with a cricket ball. These things can and do happen, but they're extremely unlikely. And let's be honest you can't ban people using the roads, or playing sport.
What you can do, is stop an event that isn't safe and is regularly claiming lives. It's the likelihood and regularity of Fatal accidents that is the issue.
280 deaths ever at the Isle Of Man TT, of which 265 are riders. Since 1911. So 106 years (excluded WW2), 2.6 deaths per year... I can't find the number of entrants per year, but it's probably around 300 in all classes... Say about 30,000 have ridden in in, gives roughly a less than 1% chance of death. Not the kind of odds I'd personally like, but I still believe it's up to the entrants...
There was 1,390 deaths on the roads in 2021 (just under 120,000 casualties)... But obviously you're talking about from millions of journeys...
Apparently, all time tandem parachuting deaths come in at around 1 in 880,000, however no deaths in the last 20 years for tandem diving.
18 recorded deaths from Bungee Jumps from 1986 to 2002, so just over 1 per year... no idea how many jumps that covered though... Apparently there's a 1 in 500,000 chance of death from Bungee Jumping.
So yes, TT is bloody dangerous and can be deadly...I still think it's up to the people who want to take part though...

