06-08-2022, 12:07 PM
(This post was last modified: 06-08-2022, 12:13 PM by Borin' Baggie.)
Fantastic, you've marginalised the hard left. What will you do when they come back? Because they will come back. Cameron thought he'd marginalised the nationalists and populists in the Tory party, now they're running the bloody country. You're never going to decouple Labour from the hard left under FPTP because the voting system encourages big tent coalitions within parties. With PR you have an avenue to shut them out of government as per Ireland and Germany, and then after the fact you can work with them externally instead of internally on a more case-by-case basis on key issues where interests align much as you can work with social liberals.
As for austerity, did you read the 2010 Labour Party manifesto? The public sector cuts that were made between 2010 and 2015 under the coalition were in line with the proposed cuts made by Labour, don't pretend that things would have been sunshine and rainbows under Labour. Labour didn't even commit to reversing the public sector cuts in the 2015 and 2017 manifestos for crying out loud. And if you want to get into the distribution of economic growth and social cohesion, that's been a longstanding issue in this country going back to Attlee. Austerity had very little to do with that. As for a budget surplus, good government should always aim to minimise the deficit when it can - that is literally the foundation of the Nordic economies which is what I expect a good social democratic party to have as a primary economic goal.
I think it's pretty obvious what needs to happen on the economy, address wealth inequality and attempt to equalise conditions for small business so they can compete with big business.
As for austerity, did you read the 2010 Labour Party manifesto? The public sector cuts that were made between 2010 and 2015 under the coalition were in line with the proposed cuts made by Labour, don't pretend that things would have been sunshine and rainbows under Labour. Labour didn't even commit to reversing the public sector cuts in the 2015 and 2017 manifestos for crying out loud. And if you want to get into the distribution of economic growth and social cohesion, that's been a longstanding issue in this country going back to Attlee. Austerity had very little to do with that. As for a budget surplus, good government should always aim to minimise the deficit when it can - that is literally the foundation of the Nordic economies which is what I expect a good social democratic party to have as a primary economic goal.
I think it's pretty obvious what needs to happen on the economy, address wealth inequality and attempt to equalise conditions for small business so they can compete with big business.


