04-03-2019, 09:14 PM
(04-03-2019, 08:17 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:(03-31-2019, 08:28 AM)Pickle Rick Wrote: I think you are right but May didn't have the backing of her party for that (or fully for anything). MPs acting as individuals as they see best may make them feel they are doing the right thing but they have just made parliament a joke incapable of moving forward. Not a fan of May but she is dealing with a bunch of divas many of whom have deliberately tried to stop the referendum result being achieved. Those against leave have sided with the EU in the negotiations in effect and strengthened their hand in trying to force a tough deal - a united response by people and parliament after the referendum may have resulted in a better deal. That's obviously impossible given the nature of the opposing views but the division in the UK is the weakness that is being exploited and will continue to be exploited by the EU and there is no good solution now. What question would a second referendum be and if we stayed in the EU how long before it kicks off again? Better to break up now than stay in a bitter marriage and deal with the custody battles as they arise. Or better the break up had not happened in the first place but it did and that wasn't just down to UKIP and Cameron but also EU economic failings and unwillingness to reform. No side cones out of this looking good.This is a top post. I normally steer clear of the politics board but, like Pandora's Box, I thought I'd have a look.
To me, the Leave movement (for a few reasons), was gathering momentum as the main parties both became ridiculously removed from real people. Everyone could see UKIP were going to take a lot of votes at the prior election but no one knew who from? Cameron called the referendum and ensured UKIP didn't take his share. Labour (IMO) were too arrogant to take any notice of the threat from UKIP, and accordingly lost.
Despite him having already said this would be his last term, Cameron decided he wasn't prepared to roll his sleeves up and see his decision through. This, I believe, is unforgivable.
As soon as the result was realised, Article 50 should have been triggered with the clear statement that after 2 years we would leave under WTO terms. Then the pressure to get a better deal would be on both Parliament and the EU but would have at least, removed much of the uncertainty faced by business.
The MPs that have stubbornly refused to accept the result could have focused on standing firm to get the best deal possible.
The EU would then not have wasted 18 months haggling over the divorce bill (which surely should come much later in the negotiation?), and would be under pressure from French and German industries to strike a deal. They would even perhaps realise they should have been a little less hasty to dismiss the UK's previous requests for a better relationship.
The referendum split family loyalties and moved many to vote for the first time. A second referendum would neither change anyone's mind, nor solve anything. It would simply move the problem back down the line. An Election, likewise.
Leaving without a deal is the stupidest thing this country will have done since Suez, and triggering Article 50 before we were ready to is why we're in this mess in the first place.
Has nobody been paying attention to anything over the last 3 years or something? We'd lose access to and from various services to the EU, EEA and other trade agreements made through them overnight which our economy relies on, our customs clearing will be crippled by checks and limitations to haulage licenses and we'd lose leverage to not only the EU but every other country if we default to WTO as we'd employ zero tariffs meaning no country would even be incentivised to sign a trade agreement as they'd not gain much and we'd gain a lot. There's a reason countries don't like using WTO rules when trading.
And by the way, the German and French industries don't care, the French industrial bodies along with their government have been pursuing a hard line since day one and the German trade bodies have stood behind their governments. That was a lie, stop repeating it.

