04-11-2022, 03:38 PM
(This post was last modified: 04-11-2022, 03:54 PM by Spandaubaggie.)
(04-11-2022, 09:33 AM)WorcsWBA Wrote:(04-11-2022, 08:45 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: The jury is out. If you think just going through managers every few months without giving them in the eyes of any football fans a chance is the way forward then we'd be in League 2 before long. It's completely barmy to bomb him out as he's sussing it out- it's also bewilderingly unreasonable.
Also as you try things out sometimes other things give. He's has had 12 games with a squad in a mess for 2 years and had been playing like a bottom 7-8 team for 3 months before he arrived.
Bruce wasn't my choice, but his pedigree over 20 years shows he's experienced and right now he has to have a chance to turn around a club in a state which he will be given unless he doesn't want it.
In the summer he will be able to use his name to get some good players in- let's have a reset and also reset our expectation as supporters.
What is barmy and bewilderingly unreasonable is booing during the 7th game of the season when we were top of the league, but that's what happened. Contrast that to "Steve Bruce's barmy army" being sung on Saturday when we were pathetically losing to Stoke.
For someone who regularly criticises others' stats, you chuck out stuff like I've highlighted above - just to point out to you that we lost just 1 game in 8 from Nov 3rd to Dec 17th (Ismael was sacked after the Millwall game on Jan 29th) and had the best defensive record in the league almost up until when Ismael was sacked. Our problem was simply not scoring enough goals, plus a total lack of patience from many fans.
Someone with over 1000 games of managerial experience should be able to come in and improve results at a club quickly and certainly not make them worse. If Bruce had done that, I'd be happy for him to stay, but W3 D3 L6 (12 points out of 36) is relegation form and it's just not good enough, particularly when you consider the remit he had when he was appointed and his willingness to accept that remit. Combine that with what happened at Newcastle earlier in the season and there has to be concern that he's become a busted flush.
If he can't improve on results before the end of the season then my view is that he won't have done enough to deserve to stay.
This is all about opinions, and the most well-constructed tend to get the most respect and others critcised- that's the way it is on all forums. So long as it's not personal then fair enough. I've criticised your views quite a bit as I find them at an extreme, and quite odd. Your belief that Val was somehow mistreated and was going to turn it around just doesn't, broadly speaking, seem to stack up.
For instance, segmenting the 1 loss in 8 between Nov and Dec 17 is completely baseless. It's as odd as saying we'd had a good mini run under Bruce before the Blues defeat so lets judge him on that little pocket of games.
Val was sacked not by me, but the club alarmed for all the reasons numerous fans have stated, and his dismissal seems overwhelmingly welcomed as there was so little that seemed positive. The results were bad, the football was dreadful. He seemed to have lost any support from the players too and had a demoralised dressing room. of course, those players need some spotlight too as we know.
Your stance with Bruce v Val is extremely hypocritical. So you wanted to give Val more time despite 19 games of terrible form following on from a good start, where he'd had an input into the personnel, which includes predominantly our weak midfield? However, you want Bruce bombed out after just 12 games with roughly the same form as Val had presided over for 3 months, where he has had no chance to bring in new personnel whatsoever.
By the way, the form's not relegation form either, but just above it. It's pretty-much on par with those last 3 months of Val you habitually paper over.
Bruce may be prove to be rubbish, but he hasn't had a chance prove it yet and you don't even want to give him half the time Val had and not even one transfer window despite his much more impressive CV than Val's!
No apologies for finding that really strange.

