02-03-2022, 12:24 AM
(This post was last modified: 02-03-2022, 12:54 AM by HawkingsHalfpint.)
Little
Pardew
Gould
Buckley
Irvine
This is a decent thread, because it is not only so very subjective, but so tough to pick. There have been quite a few!
Little gets top spot. Given the high hopes because he was a high(ish) profile name at the time, it was an utter disaster, and would surely have seen us extinct eventually had it been allowed to continue. His hands were tied a little having to sell Killer, but despite this still enjoyed more than enough residual talent at his disposal to excuse seeing us drop quite so low. Our fitness was shite, the football was dire; and some of the signings he made abysmal. Thankfully Megson and his deadline day activity saved the day, but it can never be underestimated what a mess we were in post-Hale, who should never really have removed the unspectacular but comparatively innocuous Smith to replace him with this oddly-coiffured Sealcunt moron.
Pardew… enough said.
Gould could be top. He was very much the nadir of our history.
Buckley was taking us back there, quickly. I also found both him and his fascination with Grimsby rejects quite loathsome. Almost as if they were splitting the signing-on fees…
Fifth choice was the hardest. It could have been Robson quite easily, because he wasn’t fit to manage us by the end, and the discipline was awful. I only spared him this list because of the great escape, and Mel only gets a reprieve for a similar reason (even though I have no doubt our survival had little to do with him and more to do with the seniors at the time). Pulis could be in there for the damage he’s done, which we still suffer to this day to some degree; but the club should have recognised not only the chronic underachievement at 40+ pts for two seasons, but his convenient constructing of his own dismissal by just not giving a shit. He should have been toast far, far sooner, and only escapes my list because, on his day, he could manage us effectively (unattractive though it was, and as unpopular as he became among the players). I also think he sensed that JRP had recognised he couldn’t take us any further without sacrificing profit, and so why should he bother either. If the overhang of a regime after its departure were the criteria, then Pulis would be top by a country mile. We’ve never been quite the same.
Couldn’t add Burkinshaw due to loyalty, and Talbot was just too stupid to have ever been given the job. The disasters pre-Talbot precede my memories of going to be fair. So in the end I plumped for Irvine to make up the numbers rather than VI, just because his 6-2-2 made Val’s 3-4-3 look reasonably sensible.
But Val only just misses out, because he’s been an utter twat here since Peterboro, for reasons of his own, stupid, stubborn undoing. He’s every bit the Albion flop, and deserves his place in our history of being remembered among this nightmarish band of buffoons.
Pardew
Gould
Buckley
Irvine
This is a decent thread, because it is not only so very subjective, but so tough to pick. There have been quite a few!
Little gets top spot. Given the high hopes because he was a high(ish) profile name at the time, it was an utter disaster, and would surely have seen us extinct eventually had it been allowed to continue. His hands were tied a little having to sell Killer, but despite this still enjoyed more than enough residual talent at his disposal to excuse seeing us drop quite so low. Our fitness was shite, the football was dire; and some of the signings he made abysmal. Thankfully Megson and his deadline day activity saved the day, but it can never be underestimated what a mess we were in post-Hale, who should never really have removed the unspectacular but comparatively innocuous Smith to replace him with this oddly-coiffured Sealcunt moron.
Pardew… enough said.
Gould could be top. He was very much the nadir of our history.
Buckley was taking us back there, quickly. I also found both him and his fascination with Grimsby rejects quite loathsome. Almost as if they were splitting the signing-on fees…
Fifth choice was the hardest. It could have been Robson quite easily, because he wasn’t fit to manage us by the end, and the discipline was awful. I only spared him this list because of the great escape, and Mel only gets a reprieve for a similar reason (even though I have no doubt our survival had little to do with him and more to do with the seniors at the time). Pulis could be in there for the damage he’s done, which we still suffer to this day to some degree; but the club should have recognised not only the chronic underachievement at 40+ pts for two seasons, but his convenient constructing of his own dismissal by just not giving a shit. He should have been toast far, far sooner, and only escapes my list because, on his day, he could manage us effectively (unattractive though it was, and as unpopular as he became among the players). I also think he sensed that JRP had recognised he couldn’t take us any further without sacrificing profit, and so why should he bother either. If the overhang of a regime after its departure were the criteria, then Pulis would be top by a country mile. We’ve never been quite the same.
Couldn’t add Burkinshaw due to loyalty, and Talbot was just too stupid to have ever been given the job. The disasters pre-Talbot precede my memories of going to be fair. So in the end I plumped for Irvine to make up the numbers rather than VI, just because his 6-2-2 made Val’s 3-4-3 look reasonably sensible.
But Val only just misses out, because he’s been an utter twat here since Peterboro, for reasons of his own, stupid, stubborn undoing. He’s every bit the Albion flop, and deserves his place in our history of being remembered among this nightmarish band of buffoons.

