01-09-2022, 07:47 AM
(01-07-2022, 12:26 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote:(01-07-2022, 12:08 PM)pindgill Wrote: This is a perfect example of weaving in semi truths with BS just justify racist genocide by racists!!!......it is damn fact that ships meant for Bengal in there worst famine of over a century were called back by Churchill as reserve stores this grain and rice ultimately rotted away and were never used....FACT
Its offensive your explanation of The Jallianwala Bagh Brigadier-General REH Dyer and his subordinates represented the King and the British army they massacred 1500 innocent unarmed Indians with over 100 children among the dead the youngest slaughtered was 6 months old!!! there over 5000 casualties these figures were from the report by INC conducted with US independent officials not that discredited white wash commissioned by Churchill The Hunter Commission.
This massacre was NOT an exception the degradation brutality and murder by and condoned by The British authorities was a daily occurrence news reports and papers confirm that.
India was one of the richest and leading trading nations when it was took over and became part of the British Empire after 250 years of brutality and plunder the British left it one of the poorest!!!...
Suggest you go educate yourself on the brief before coming out with such obvious BS...![]()
![]()
![]()
But I was never taught about the Jallianwala Bagh as part of history syllabus at school. Learnt of the black hole of calcutta though!
Your emotive post Pindgill may not be 100% correct but at least its not lifted from unsourced publication as it appears JOK has.
I await his follow up to your reply.
How did Britain cause the Typhoon? How did Britain cause the rice blight?
I did write that military considerations added to the situation. I wrote of the home front’s need being used to trump calls for relief aid. I wrote of the cabinet’s decision to insist on a proviso that supplies were unequally targeted to the military.
So, Tharoor, referring to a ‘scientific’ study, says there was more moisture in the soil in 1943 than in 1941. Not surprising considering there had been a typhoon. (A study based on modelling, decades after the events, incidentally, and we have recent evidence of how accurate that can be, don’t we?)
Saying India was a wealthy country until the British arrived is ridiculous. There was certainly a lot of wealth there but only in the hands of a very select few. Much as in almost every country on Earth, including Britain at that time.
If you have all the historical sources, give the examples of all the ‘slaughters.’ Being accused a being a racist because I take differing sources to gain a whole picture rather than the one sided views of biased parties of any persuasion is cheap. Perhaps you missed the phrase ‘ I refuse to accept the blame for past generations ‘. You can put as many angry faces as you like, I will continue to point out that the interpretation of past events, using a mix of sources, both primary and secondary, is far more nuanced than accepting your particular flavour of history. The story of states interactions with other states and man’s sensibilities is not confined to a two hundred year slot and only one nation. It may surprise you but it was not only the British who were less than philanthropic over the centuries and many still aren’t.
If you wish to tie me with the epithet ‘racist’ when you do not know me and because you can’t understand the concept of historical interpretations based on rigorous, multi sourced, study or take an overly simplistic view of the past, then I think I am allowed to call you Imbeciles. You can believe your revisionist history writers, just a others can believe Imperial era written history, but don’t accuse me of racism because I research and interpret many disparate sources and come to conclusions that do not agree with your biases. Am I a misogynist if I point out that for 50 years women retired 5 years earlier than men? Am I a communist if I refer to how the working class of Britain were treated until the second half of the 20c?
When you say the “INC enquiry” what is that ? Are you referring to the Indian National Congress Enquiry Committee? (Bound to be un-biased) which claimed approx. 1000 killed which were included in the total casualty figure of approx. 1500. (Large proportion of killed to injured) and 47 boys and one infant. not quite the figures you state! The Independent Servants of India committee under Seva Simiti and Led by Pandit M.M. Malviya and likely to be as independent as any committee, gave the death toll as 379. I can find no references to U.S. officials being involved with ANY inquiry!
To dismiss the incompetence shown by local officials and attribute it to official government policy is revisionist. It could be argued that the lack of consequences from the government towards Dyer, though severely censured, is tantamount to ‘acceptance’ or “indifference” as J. Mukherjee suggests, it is still not official policy. Was it government policy to massacre 18 peaceful, family demonstrators in Manchester?
Taking narrow views in isolation of Geo-political events in the past is naive and not the correct or academic interpretation of the historical past.
Good for your school RSBaggy, I received my education when the empire was still taught reverently and I was never taught about the Nawab of Bengal and his actions at Fort William.
Sources used for original post. (I get criticised for citing all my sources by some on here)
Amartya Sen. Who argued in 1981 that there should still have been enough supplies to feed the region, and that the mass deaths came about as a combination of wartime inflation, speculative buying and panic hoarding, (seen that a couple of times recently, haven’t we?) which together pushed the price of food out of the reach of poor Bengalis.
An Era of Darkness. Shashi Tharoor.
Insurgent Empire. Pryamvada Gopal.
Total war and Social Change 1919-1945. Arthur Marwick.
Churchills Secret War. M. Mukergee. (Which cites ONE contemporary journalist as a source of evidence for the “waste” of rice! )
Hungry Bengal: War, Famine, Riots and the End of Empire . Janam Mukherjee. (In which he describes Churchills Secret War as belonging to the "nationalist mode of Indian historiography", but that it "nevertheless provides moving insight into the colossal indifference that characterized London's attitude toward starving Bengal".
Warfare in Pre-British India – 1500BCE to 1740CE. Kaushik Roy.
Colonialism as Civilizing Mission: Cultural Ideology in British India. Harald Fischer-Tiné, Michael Mann (Editors)
The rise and fall of the British Empire. Professor Patrick Allitt.
Victorian Britain. Professor Patrick Allitt.
The Amritsar Massacre: The Untold Story of One Fateful Day. Nick Lloyd.
So. my post was not just “lifted” from “ A publication”.

