01-07-2022, 11:51 AM
(This post was last modified: 01-07-2022, 11:57 AM by Brentbaggie.)
(01-07-2022, 10:11 AM)JOK Wrote:(01-06-2022, 09:28 AM)Sotv Wrote:
And we all know what the result would be. Strange how we still venerate those responsible for the slaughter of millions under the British Raj.
“Slaughter”: Massacre, Murder, Killing, Butchery. (Concise O.E.D.)
Explain how and when these millions were “Slaughtered”.
If you’re referring to the 1940s famine. Again, I’ll ask the question which was ignored the last time this came up. Did the British instigate the myriad of physical conditions which resulted in that catastrophe in Bengal? Britain was struggling to feed its own citizens thanks to the Atlantic wolf packs and loosing hundreds of thousands of tons of ships and men in the process. (You may not be aware but there was another man-made catastrophe underway at the time) Where would Britain get all the surplus food and transport to get it to India. Or would you have preferred Britons to starve and fall to the Nazis?
Famines were a recurring event in the pre-colonial Sub Continent. Famines in the Deccan in 1460, 1520 and 1629. The 1629-1632 famine in the Deccan and Gujarat, was one of the greatest in India's history. In the first 10 months of 1631 an estimated 3 million perished in Gujarat and one million in the Deccan. More famines hit the Deccan in 1655, 1682. Another famine in 1702–1704 killed over two million people. The oldest famine in Deccan with records sufficiently well-preserved for study is the Doji bara famine of 1791-1792.
According to Mushtaq Kaw, "Many Famines were recorded in Kashmir from the sixteenth to eighteenth centuries. Contemporary sources point to the occurrence of many famines. They also show that these famines were on a great scale.
In 1942 there was a mass exodus from Burma, of over half a million Indians, back into Bengal, due to the Invasion of Burma by the Japanese. The poor hygienic conditions of their journey caused diseases such as dysentery, cholera, smallpox and malaria, The influx of refugees into Bengal created several conditions that contributed to the famine. This influx created an increased demand for food, clothing and medical aid.
Japanese warships and aircraft had sunk approximately 100,000 tons of merchant shipping, bringing in supplies, in the Bay of Bengal alone. The fall of Rangoon cut off the import of vital Burmese rice into India. The colonial military did exacerbate the situation with a partial ‘scorched Earth’ policy to deny the anticipated Japanese invaders access to food and transport (rail and shipping)
Some of the semi-autonomous provinces and ‘princely states’ instigated trade barriers between provinces, restricting the sale of foods between them.
The Bengal region was affected by a series of natural disasters in late 1942. The winter rice crop was afflicted by a severe outbreak of fungal diseases. There was a cyclone in October and three storm surges devastated crops and destroyed homes, killing thousands. The fungus reduced the crop yield even more. S. Y. Padmanabhan wrote “Though administrative failures were immediately responsible for this human suffering; the principal cause of the short crop production of 1942 was the epidemic (of plant blight) ... nothing as devastating ... has ever been recorded in plant pathological literature"
The Bengal cyclone killed 14,500 people and 190,000 cattle, whilst rice paddy stocks were destroyed. It also created local atmospheric conditions that contributed to an increased incidence of malaria. The storm surges destroyed seawalls and flooded large areas. Waves swept an area of 450 square miles, floods affected 400 square miles (1,000 km2), and wind and torrential rain damaged 3,200 square miles. Britain, of course, caused all these natural phenomena. (Thunberg does!)
The viceroy, the Indian government and Lord Mountbatten did make repeated calls for more relief but the efforts were severely reduced by the War Cabinet and only allowed on the proviso of ‘military first’. (Bear in mind the state of the war on all fronts at that time though.)
Not quite as simple as the trope ‘the evil British let them starve’ or the use of hyperbolic emotive words, is it?
If you are referring to the Jallianwala Bagh massacre, that was not carried out as Imperial government policy but, as usual, resulted from misinformation, panic and incompetence between a few local officials. (As happened at Petersfield in Manchester) Strangely that obnoxious imperial racist, Churchill, condemned it as “utterly monstrous” in both the House and press. Casualty figures are disputed. Various commissions put deaths at between 279 and 400 (Churchill’s figure) to 1500 (reported by an Indian nationalist without a proper investigation). To get to even 1 million “slaughtered” there would have had to have been around 2,500 Bagh type massacres, which there were not.
Then whilst you consider that from the comfortable distance of 70 years, can we consider the millions of widows saved from Suttee after the British banned the practice and the thousands saved thanks to The Raj crackdown on the Thuggee and the enactment of the Criminal Tribes Act.
Of course, all the various Maharajas and their fiefdoms lived in perfect peace and harmony and never tried to take over each other in the period between Mogul rule and British rule. There was obviously no loss of life or slaughters then! Perhaps you could investigate the inter province wars and atrocities on the sub-continent of that period. How many hundred of thousands were spared from that being stopped for 200 years?
The past is not quite so black and white as some like to suggest or, in their ignorance, believe. Still, as long as we can find a stick to beat our ancestors and their outdated values with eh. I refuse to accept guilt for the actions of our ancestors, of at least, five generations past and more.
Very interesting post JOK but as you well know, facts and the unsettling interpretation of historical events are not welcome on this bored so cut it out.
As to the Colston 4 ( I think it sounds more like a toothpaste to be honest) case not setting a precedent I see that Grant Shapps is very keen to explore the possibility that such acts do not do so. In law the case may well not be precedent-setting, but Mr Shapps clearly doesn't like the idea of people going round smashing up property and causing criminal damage. I wonder what he's scared of?
Last night on the news I noticed that there was a suggestion that rather than the statue of deeply unpleasant but rather wealthy racist Cecil Rhodes be taken down, which Oriel College, Oxford have rejected, it should be turned round so that he faces the college wall. I thought this a rather nice idea. Perhaps we should have plebiscites to determine which public statues the public deem truly offensive and those that pass the 50% criterion are not removed or destroyed but turned upside down. Simples.

