11-11-2021, 10:54 PM
(This post was last modified: 11-12-2021, 09:14 AM by Derek Hardballs.)
(11-11-2021, 09:41 PM)JOK Wrote:(11-11-2021, 10:28 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: No you are arguing with me. Your ‘facts’ can be questioned and a counter argument for them can be put forward, which is all you are doing whenever I post, regardless of the credentials of those who I link to, including on most occasions experts in their field. This is a general point rather than specific to your reply.Do you read your posts? They get more ridiculous by the day.
Specific to your point, you’re using the same argument over and over again that other countries are suffering global problems. We know this, we have acknowledged this, so you’re making moot points. The point has always been you are stubbornly trying to argue that the problems Brexit has brought will not exasperate global difficulties here in the U.K.
We (the country) thanks to the referendum told thousands of potential hard working, talented and upstanding people from across Europe that they aren’t needed or welcome unless they can earn over circa £30k. Whilst spending a few million telling those who had already made a home here, contributed to the U.K. socially and economically and in many cases married or have families with U.K. nationals that they could stay. That was big of us!
Freedom of movement is a lot more helpful to help the U.K. with a shortage of workers than stopping freedom of movement. If someone from Romania or Poland want to work in the U.K. and contribute to both countries economically (which most do) then that’s up to them. We live in a global economy so why would we hobble ‘global Britain’ by limiting people’s freedoms to work where they wish?
I don’t think this country is best served by this government. I will carry on pointing out the catalogue of reasons why. Others are free to argue to the contrary. You are on a politics board, it’s going to party political and if you’re just going to pick fault with other people’s opinions whilst trying to stay aloof from offering your own then fine, a bit odd and weakens your position but ok all the same.
You can argue with a country’s official inflation figure? Do give us the benefit of your “counter argument “ to that fact.
Our problems are being experienced by many countries worldwide. Give us the benefit of your “counter argument “ for that.
It is you who is “stubbornly trying to argue” that the same problems in the U.K. are solely caused by Brexit. And you, for one, certainly has not acknowledge it as a global concern by continually inferring that they are just a U.K. phenomena.
Facts can’t be argued. Facts are not an opinion. They are facts. Not your ‘Meghanesque’ “My truth”.
So, finally you admit that you are happy to hobble other state’s economies simply for your benefit and convenience. How very ‘global’, compassionate and internationalist of you.
Now just the answer to the question; if Freedom of Movement is the answer to the U.K.’s problems why are countries who have the ‘benefit’ of Freedom of Movement, also suffering the same problems?
I am not taking a position so how can I be weakening it? Are you saying I am not allowed to highlight inaccuracies and falsehoods and fact ignoring “my truths” in posts?
One last point. Are you admitting you are taking a “party political “ stance. I thought you abhorred “football supporting” style politics?
This is ridiculous, myself and others have acknowledged time and time again that global problems are impacting the U.K. However you will not accept that Brexit will exasperate many of the problems we face be it in logistics, rising food prices, shortages of workers. No point even debating anything with you if you cannot even acknowledge this.
Freedom of movement was a choice for millions of people here and across Europe. I’d rather people whether they were rich or poor had the choice to live and work where they wanted within the EU. I would rather a lorry driver for example could work across Europe helping the economies of several countries relatively unhindered by needless red tape.
You don’t highlight inaccuracies free from bias, you look to find ‘facts’ that back your opinions up. You've dismissed reports, experts, statistics and other people’s life experiences if they don’t fit your point of view. That’s fine we are all susceptible to this, but If you want to set yourself up as the boards watchdog then recognise your own conscious or unconscious bias.
I don’t think it’s any secret lol that I don’t like this Tory government or the previous one, because of their actions not some deep seated admiration for Labour or the Lib Dem’s. I’ve never been a member of any political party. I make no secret of my dislike and distrust of the incumbent party. You try and argue that you are above political bias your replies on here suggest otherwise.
‘Not your ‘Meghanesque’ “My truth”.’ Hmm how very right of centre tabloid of you
Tarabit I’ve wasted far too much time on this merry-go-round of arguments.


