10-28-2021, 11:38 AM
(10-28-2021, 10:21 AM)MassDebater Wrote:(10-28-2021, 10:00 AM)Squid Wrote:(10-28-2021, 07:35 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:(10-27-2021, 09:15 PM)Squid Wrote: It matters when health services are too scared to use the word "women" so use confusing language like "people with cervixes" when 50% of women don't actually know what a cervix is. Note that Prostate cancer charities still use the world "men"
You're not referring to the tweet that was aimed at people who have a cervix but aren't on the register for regular screening so need to actively be encouraged by external sources to get a smear test, are you? I'll let you guess the composition of those who have cervix and aren't on the register for smear tests. Hint: trans men over the age of 25 in this country usually have cervixes as hysterectomies weren't offered on the NHS until recently for transition, but they are taken off the register by the NHS to be contacted for smear tests.
"People with cervixes" has been used far more widely than one tweet.
The Lancet saw fit to use the even more dehumanising "Bodies with vaginas" on their front cover recently. Apparently this was them being "inclusive".
Do not even try to defend the use of that kind of terminology. It is bad enough living in a world with sexual predators who view women solely as walking holes, without a medical journal using similar words.
What you are discussing with regards to trans men is a failure of the NHS date collection, which currently allows people to change their sex marker on their NHS records. While well-intentioned is potentially very dangerous, as it means trans people can miss out on the healthcare they actually need, as in the case of this trans man who was pregnant and had a still born baby, due to staff not realising they were in labour until it was too late:
https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/heal...692201002/
The solution to this issue is to add a category to medical records which captures gender transition, so that people are invited to the screening services their body requires.
The solution is not make health care information harder to understand for 50% of the population, especially women with learning disabilities or limited English skills.
As with all changes, and let's face it the NHS has monumental data issues already, adding something to do with their transition will cost many millions to add. Millions that could well save several other people's actual lives, it's not an easy one to justify on that basis. How many actual trans-prev-men are there that are missing out on essential treatments? And surely, if they have transitioned then surely it should be up to them to be fighting for it, surely they are aware of whether or not they have a cervix, need screening etc...? Heck, I know regular types who miss out on their treatment, because they don't know they need it, so why should we spend millions (or more) extending a system for a tiny minority?
Sounds harsh, and maybe I am being, but I'm fed up of loads of money being spent to benefit tiny minorities when majorities are already missing out.
What are the majorities missing out on?

